Scroll.in - India https://scroll.in A digital daily of things that matter. http://www.rssboard.org/rss-specification python-feedgen http://s3-ap-southeast-1.amazonaws.com/scroll-feeds/scroll_logo_small.png Scroll.in - India https://scroll.in en Fri, 20 Nov 2026 22:56:46 +0000 Fri, 20 Nov 2026 00:00:00 +0000 Nikhil Gupta sentenced for 20 years in plot to assassinate Sikh separatist leader in New York https://scroll.in/article/1097218/nikhil-gupta-sentenced-for-20-years-in-plot-to-assassinate-sikh-separatist-leader-in-new-york?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Gupta had acted on the directions of an employee of the Indian government to kill an American citizen based on his political ideology, US prosecutors said.

On November 20, a US federal judge sentenced Nikhil Gupta to 19 years and seven months in prison for a failed assasination plot that targeted Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, an American-Sikh lawyer and a Khalistan separatist leader in New York.

Since Gupta pleaded guilty in February, his sentencing had been postponed three times.

The sentence was announced in a hearing that took nearly two hours. The US government’s argument was clear: Gupta had acted on the directions of an employee of the Indian government to kill an American citizen based on his political ideology. Gupta, they said, was an active and “enthusiastic” participant in the plot.

Gupta’s defense team argued that his role was not all that significant: he was just an “intermediary” and not central to the plot to kill Pannun. According to Gupta’s lawyers, there is no evidence that he had a criminal history before a man, claiming to be an Indian intelligence official, knocked on his door asking to speak to his son.

Gupta, they said, acted under pressure.

The official in question was Vikash Yadav, who at the time was an employee of India’s cabinet secretariat, which houses the Research and Analysis Wing. Yadav has been on the US Federal Bureau of Investigation’s “most wanted” list since October 2024. He had been arrested in India on a kidnapping and extortion case in Delhi in December 2023, but was granted bail in April 2024. Yadav’s whereabouts are now unknown.

The Indian authorities, who have said that the contentions about the country’s involvement in the plot are “fabricated and malicious”, are yet to comment on Gupta’s sentencing.

Right before the judge ordered the sentence followed by deportation to India, Gupta apologised in court. He said he had hoped to live by the ideals of Nelson Mandela, Martin Luther King, Mother Teresa and Mahatma Gandhi but had ended up turning his back on them.

Now, Gupta said, he was delivering the “message of Gandhi”. “No one can achieve anything by a bullet,” he said.

Outside the courtroom in Manhattan, Khalistan supporters had erected full-length cutouts of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Home Minister Amit Shah and External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar wearing prison clothes and in handcuffs.

Around 200 members of the Sikh diaspora had gathered chanting slogans in support of Khalistan. A small section of the crowd filmed themselves tearing the Indian national flag while chanting “Balkanise India.”

A few minutes before the hearing, Pannun arrived to a hero’s welcome. He is the general counsel and spokesperson for Sikhs for Justice, a pro-Khalistan group that holds frequent referendums on creating Khalistan, the separate Sikh homeland carved out of Punjab state.

Sikhs For Justice came to prominence in the US by filing lawsuits against Indian politicians whom it alleged were involved in the anti-Sikh violence of 1984, after Prime Minister Indira Gandhi was assassinated by two of her Sikh bodyguards.

In 2019, Sikhs For Justice was designated a terrorist organisation in India.

Pannun has made statements against everyone from India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi to Congress leader Sonia Gandhi to the architect of India’s Constitution BR Ambedkar. The US State Department is yet to accede to India’s request designate him as a terrorist.

In the courtroom, a little before his assailant’s sentencing hearing was scheduled to begin at 10 am on Friday, Pannun sat on the third row, with a bodyguard next to him.

Court records say that in May 2023, Yadav, who US authorities later identified as a former Indian intelligence officer, allegedly recruited Indian national Gupta to arrange the assassination of Pannun, who holds American and Canadian citizenship, in New York. He had been followed for days before his planned killing.

According to US prosecutors, Gupta approached a man he believed to be a criminal, specifically a large-scale drug trafficker, to find a contract killer. The man was actually a confidential informant working with the US Drug Enforcement Administration. He is identified as “Pacho Sanchez” in correspondence filed in court.

Sanchez introduced Gupta to an undercover Drug Enforcement Administration agent, listed in the records as “Carlos”, who was posing as a hitman.

Gupta and Yadav allegedly gave the undercover agent Pannun’s home address, telephone numbers, notes about his daily routine and surveillance photographs. Gupta spoke to the undercover agent for days, court filings show.

Between June 4 and June 5, 2023, court documents show that Gupta cut a deal with the informant, Sanchez. Prosecutors allege that Yadav, working through Gupta, agreed to pay $100,000 for the killing.

On or about June 9, Yadav and Gupta arranged through an associate of Yadav to deliver $15,000 to Carlos, the undercover agent posing as the hitman, as an advance payment for the murder.

But plotting to murder Pannun was just the beginning, according to communications seized by Czech Republic law enforcement officers after Gupta was arrested in Prague in the midst of the planning,

On June 18, 2023, a Khalistan supporter in Canada named Hardeep Singh Nijjar was shot and killed outside a gurudwara in Surrey, British Columbia. The next day, the US undercover agent called Gupta.

“My friend, my friend,” he said, transcripts attached in court filings showed. “I saw the video. You, you scare me. What’s, what’s that? I don’t, I don’t, I don’t know who that is.”

Gupta responded: “Uh, this is the one job, uh, in Canada. Canada – we have three job. So one, somebody did. So I was wondering if you did that, but we found who did that.”

Nijjar, as per Gupta’s communication with the agent, was one of the targets. “Not to worry,” Gupta told the undercover agent. “We have so many target. We have so many target,”

Gupta and Yadav initially instructed the agent to postpone the assassination until after Prime Minister Narendra Modi's June 2023 state visit to the US. However, following the killing of Nijjar in Canada, Gupta told the agent there was no longer any need to wait, filing by the prosecutors showed.

On June 20, Gupta wrote to the man he thought was the hitman, with instructions about Pannun.

“And if, if, if he’s not alone, he has one more, two guys always with him… Fucking finish them also!” said Gupta, as per a transcript of a phone call filed in court. “Finish them also. No problem, Before 29th, we have to finish four jobs, brother. One is in, this is job, and after three in Canada.”

The plot was foiled before the assassination could be carried out. Gupta was arrested in the Czech Republic on June 30, 2023, by Czech police on the request of the US Justice Department and extradited to the US a year later, in June 2024. On February 13 this year, he pleaded guilty to murder-for-hire, conspiracy to commit murder-for-hire and conspiracy to commit money laundering.

Yadav has also been charged in the US but remains at large.

The US prosecution also said that around the same time in May and June 2023, Gupta and Yadav were planning another murder of an individual in Nepal or Pakistan. It is unclear from their communications if they managed to carry out this hit.

The submission by the prosecution also showed that as part of the deal to murder Pannun, Yadav offered on June 22, 2023, to arrange the sale of AK-56 rifles and M20 pistols to the hitman planning the murder from which Gupta expected to profit. Yadav also offered to arrange airport clearance in Imphal, Manipur, for an aircraft said to be carrying drugs.

“Most things will depend upon the task at hand.. if it’s done in an impeccable manner…all will be take care of bhai ji,” a message from Yadav to Gupta purportedly said.

Speaking to the judge before the sentencing, Gupta said, “I have had long days with my own thoughts and I realise I have nowhere to hide from what I had done by joining this conspiracy…”

He added: “Whether I was under pressure or not, the choices were completely mine and I own it completely. I am sorry to Pannun, communities that I have hurt and to my own family that loved me even though I did not deserve it”.

]]>
https://scroll.in/article/1097218/nikhil-gupta-sentenced-for-20-years-in-plot-to-assassinate-sikh-separatist-leader-in-new-york?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 20:56:31 +0000 Oishika Neogi
Bengal: EC postpones special summary revision of electoral roll https://scroll.in/latest/1097217/bengal-ec-postpones-special-summary-revision-of-electoral-roll?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The action was taken due to ‘some unavoidable circumstances’, said the chief electoral officer.

The special summary revision of the 2027 electoral roll in West Bengal, which was scheduled to begin on November 23, has been postponed, said the office of the chief electoral officer on Friday.

The poll official said that the exercise was postponed due to “some unavoidable circumstances” and the modified schedule would be “intimated subsequently”.

On November 13, the Election Commission announced the schedule for the special summary revision of electoral rolls in West Bengal. The draft rolls after the exercise were to be published on November 23 and the final voters’ list on January 16.

The revision will use January 1, 2027, as the qualifying date, making those who turn 18 by then eligible to register as voters, the poll panel had said.

The annual special summary revision was paused after the 2024 Lok Sabha elections because of the special intensive revision, which began in 2025 and is underway in some states and Union Territories.

While the special summary revision involves updating the electoral rolls through additions and deletions, under the special intensive revision, voter lists are prepared afresh.

In West Bengal, the special intensive revision was carried out ahead of the Assembly elections in April. The final rolls published in February initially excluded more than 61 lakh voters, with the process continuing through supplementary lists and adjudication of about 60 lakh “doubtful and pending” cases.

By April 6, ahead of the Assembly elections, about 91 lakh voters, nearly 11.9% of West Bengal’s electorate before the revision process began, had been removed from the electoral rolls.

Appeals were allowed to be filed before tribunals against decisions taken during the exercise.

In September, the Election Commission told the Supreme Court that 22.2 lakh of these voters had appealed against their exclusion, of which 93% of the cases decided by the tribunals had resulted in the restoration of their names.

Scroll’s analysis of the Assembly election results in West Bengal found that in half the seats that the Bharatiya Janata Party won, the total deletions that took place during the voter list revision exercise outnumbered the victory margin. While the BJP won 207 seats in the 294-member Assembly, the Trinamool Congress won 80.

Written by Anamika Pathak. Edited by Sneha.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097217/bengal-ec-postpones-special-summary-revision-of-electoral-roll?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 15:03:10 +0000 Scroll Staff
‘Your own confession’: Rahul Gandhi after Modi says tax cuts didn’t hike salaries, create jobs https://scroll.in/latest/1097216/your-own-confession-rahul-gandhi-after-modi-says-tax-cuts-didnt-hike-salaries-create-jobs?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The prime minister had said that corporate leaders’ ‘appetite is so insatiable, no matter how much you are given, it is never enough’.

Rahul Gandhi, the leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha, said on Friday that Prime Minister Narendra Modi had made a “confession” when he said a day ago that corporate leaders had not passed on the benefits of tax cuts to their employees.

Speaking at the annual convention of the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry on Thursday, Modi said that the corporate tax rate has been reduced to 22% from 30% since 2014. “But have you increased the salaries of your employees?” the prime minister had asked. “Have you increased the number of employees in your organisations? No.”

He added that corporate leaders had not done so “because your appetite is so insatiable, no matter how much you are given, it is never enough”.

On Friday, Gandhi said that Modi’s remarks were not accusations against corporate leaders, but “they are your own confession”.

In an apparent reference to businesspersons Gautam Adani and Mukesh Ambani, the Congress leader said: “The whole country knows who is hungry.”

“Airports, ports, mines, forests, electricity, coal, roads – all handed over to them,” he added. “How many jobs did they create?”

He accused Modi of “destroying” micro, small and medium enterprises with demonetisation and a “flawed” goods and services tax. He also alleged that the Bharatiya Janata Party government had “wiped out” the level playing field for large companies.

“Monopoly does not create jobs,” Gandhi said. “It drives up prices and eliminates competition. Modi ji, you and your friends did the looting—the country saw it, and is still seeing it.”

Gandhi has repeatedly accused the Modi government of favouring the two industrialists.

Reacting to the remarks by Modi on Thursday, Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge said that the prime minister “blamed the business community for his own failures”.

“…the Modi government handed over all the country’s resources to one-two crony capitalists and broke the backs of MSMEs and small traders,” Kharge said. “The lack of healthy competition stifled innovation, compromised manufacturing quality, and weakened the credibility and global brand value of Indian products.”

Written by Anamika Pathak. Edited by Sneha.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097216/your-own-confession-rahul-gandhi-after-modi-says-tax-cuts-didnt-hike-salaries-create-jobs?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 14:38:38 +0000 Scroll Staff
Ask Them Anything: On Scroll’s new show, an air pollution expert on why he has failed as a father https://scroll.in/video/1097201/ask-them-anything-on-scrolls-new-show-an-air-pollution-expert-on-why-he-has-failed-as-a-father?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt A new show in which Scroll reporters take your questions to experts.

When Sunil Dahiya recently became a father, he wondered if he had failed.

As the founder of the environment and climate consultancy Envirocatalysts, Dahiya has been working on air pollution mitigation for 14 years. But the air quality in northern India has remained abysmal. As the father of a newborn, Dahiya is acutely aware of the price of this failure.

In this first episode of Ask Them Anything, a show where experts answer questions sent in by readers, Dahiya answers the question on the minds of many residents in Delhi and North India: why does the region have the world’s most toxic air?

He also explains the reasoning behind several other burning questions: how did Beijing successfully clean its air, how you can check your air quality index without being confused by varying AQI values across platforms, and why even coastal cities like Mumbai are struggling with bad air.

Catch the full conversation with Dahiya on our YouTube channel.

Host: Vaishnavi Rathore

Production: Priyali Dhingra

Graphics: Pankaj Pandey

]]>
https://scroll.in/video/1097201/ask-them-anything-on-scrolls-new-show-an-air-pollution-expert-on-why-he-has-failed-as-a-father?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 13:30:00 +0000 Vaishnavi Rathore
Rush Hour: SC rejects TN plea for more Cauvery water, US panel says SIR targeting Muslims and more https://scroll.in/latest/1097215/rush-hour-sc-rejects-tn-plea-for-more-cauvery-water-us-panel-says-sir-targeting-muslims-and-more?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Become a Scroll member to get Rush Hour – a wrap of the day’s important stories delivered straight to your inbox every evening.

Could your home be at risk from rising seas? Scroll is investigating coastal flooding in Mumbai and Kolkata, mapping vulnerable areas and examining whether developers and the authorities are accounting for the risks. Support this investigation and help us make this reporting possible. Fund the project here.


The Supreme Court dismissed two applications by the Tamil Nadu government seeking that Karnataka be directed to release additional water from the Cauvery river. The Tamil Nadu government had approached the court seeking the immediate release of 3,500 cusecs of water a day for 15 days from the Kabini and Krishna Raja Sagara reservoirs in Karnataka.

Tamil Nadu had alleged that Karnataka had failed to release its due share of water despite having sufficient storage in its reservoirs. However, Karnataka refuted the claim, maintaining that it was complying with the directions of the Cauvery Water Management Authority.

The distribution of Cauvery water has been a long-standing dispute between Tamil Nadu and Karnataka. Read on.


India has heightened its targeting of Muslims ​during the special intensive revision of electoral rolls, a United States panel ‌on religious freedom alleged. The US Commission on International Religious Freedom quoted its head Asif Mahmood as alleging that the Indian government was “targeting Muslim citizens by removing them from voter rolls, calling them ‘foreigners’, and now illegally deporting” them.

The panel also quoted its Commissioner Gene Mills as saying that the Indian government’s “expulsion of its own citizens based on their Muslim faith is a shocking escalation of tactics that target religious minorities”. Read on.


The Supreme Court on Friday, as a one-time measure, allowed a lamp to be lit at a stone pillar on Thiruparankundram hill near Madurai in Tamil Nadu on the Hindu festival of Karthigai Deepam. However, the bench stayed the Madras High Court’s observation that the pillar is located on land that belongs to the Subramania Swamy temple.

The Supreme Court held that the lamp may be lit only by a small team from the temple. The bench also barred public gatherings, processions, demonstrations and the shouting of slogans at the site.

It said that worship at customary sites and lawful access to the nearby dargah and mosque must continue undisturbed. The court clarified that neither the permission nor the ceremony could be treated as proof of an established custom or a right of access, or as a basis for seeking permission in subsequent years. Read on.


The Supreme Court upheld the Karnataka High Court’s January judgement permitting bike taxis to operate in the state. It was better to regulate bike taxis than ban them, a bench said while dismissing the Karnataka government’s petition challenging the High Court’s January 23 order.

“Bike taxi is safer for young girls as it has GPS [global positioning system] as well,” the bench held. “Bike taxi is already there in 25 states.” Read on.


If you haven’t already, sign up for our Daily Brief newsletter.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097215/rush-hour-sc-rejects-tn-plea-for-more-cauvery-water-us-panel-says-sir-targeting-muslims-and-more?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 12:37:52 +0000 Scroll Staff
Madhya Pradesh cited non-existent SC order in legal submission drafted by AI https://scroll.in/latest/1097213/madhya-pradesh-cited-non-existent-sc-order-in-legal-submission-drafted-by-ai?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The High Court criticised the government for the ‘callous and irresponsible manner’ in which the reply was filed.

The Madhya Pradesh High Court has criticised the state government for having “blindly resorted to the use of artificial intelligence tools” and citing a non-existent Supreme Court ruling in drafting its reply to a petition challenging the dismissal of a police officer.

“…this court is constrained to take serious note of the callous and irresponsible manner in which the return has been drafted on behalf of the state,” the court said in an order passed on Tuesday.

Justice Vivek Kumar Singh said that the Bharatiya Janata Party government in Madhya Pradesh had, in its submission, cited a purported judgement of the Supreme Court titled State of Andhra Pradesh vs. SS Mohammad Nisar. The judgement was attributed to the citation “(2008) 5 SCC 230”.

However, the court said that no such judgement exists and the citation “(2008) 5 SCC 230” actually refers to Sidhartha Vashisht alias Manu Sharma vs. State (NCT of Delhi), a case concerning the suspension of sentence in a criminal appeal and an entirely different subject matter.

“It is glaringly apparent that the respondents have blindly resorted to the use of artificial intelligence tools to draft their pleadings, resulting in the incorporation of a fabricated case name cross-wired with an unrelated citation,” the court said.

It added that pleadings filed before a constitutional court are “solemn documents” and that inserting fictitious case laws without verifying citations not only wastes judicial time but also “borders on actively misleading the court.”

The court was hearing a petition filed by a former Madhya Pradesh Police officer who was dismissed from service in May 2024 after a woman cleaner deployed at the police headquarters in Bhopal accused him of behaving “objectionably” with her.

Piyush Mani Tiwari, who was an acting sub-inspector when the complaint was submitted, said that he was dismissed from service without a show-cause notice, chargesheet or departmental inquiry.

The state had justified its decision, saying that the complaint involved a woman employee and prolonging the matter through an inquiry could have caused distress and public outrage. It also said that there was a likelihood of witness intimidation.

On Tuesday, the court quashed the dismissal order and directed the state to reinstate Tiwari, while allowing it to initiate and conduct a regular departmental inquiry.

Written by Anamika Pathak. Edited by Sneha.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097213/madhya-pradesh-cited-non-existent-sc-order-in-legal-submission-drafted-by-ai?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 11:59:49 +0000 Scroll Staff
SC allows bike taxis in Karnataka, dismisses state’s plea to ban them https://scroll.in/latest/1097210/sc-allows-bike-taxis-in-karnataka?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The court said that it was better to regulate bike taxis than to ban them.

The Supreme Court on Friday upheld the Karnataka High Court’s January judgement permitting bike taxis to operate in the state, Live Law reported.

It was better to regulate bike taxis than ban them, a bench said while dismissing the Karnataka government’s petition challenging the High Court’s January 23 order.

“Bike taxi is safer for young girls as it has GPS [global positioning system] as well,” Live Law quoted Justice Satish Chandra Sharma as saying. “Bike taxi is already there in 25 states.”

In April 2025, a single-judge bench of the Karnataka High Court had directed all bike taxi services to stop operating in the state within six weeks. The court had referred to a 2019 expert committee report that examined the impact of bike taxis on traffic and safety.

It had held that motorcycles could not be used as taxis unless the state government framed rules and guidelines permitting their operation.

On June 13, 2025 a division bench refused to stay the High Court’s order. However, the court sought the response of state authorities on appeals filed by the cab aggregators against the ban, while rejecting their request to continue interim relief.

During their arguments in court, the cab aggregators had said that the ban violated their fundamental right to trade under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution.

The cab aggregators had also said that the state government cannot, by executive action, claim to have a larger right and override all these provisions, as that would be in contravention of the 1988 Motor Vehicles Act.

On the other hand, the state government had argued that a motorcycle cannot be a transport vehicle. It added that the statutory definition did not contemplate its use for carrying passengers or for hire.

If a motorcycle were to be considered a transport vehicle, “it is not a passenger vehicle and not to be used for hire or reward”, it had added.

However, the Karnataka High Court in January held that bikes used for taxi services fell within the definition of “transport vehicles” under the Motor Vehicles Act. It added that the state government cannot refuse or deny permits to such vehicles on the grounds that bikes were not transport vehicles.

Edited by Sneha.


Also read: Bike taxis are exploding in India – but are facing government roadblocks


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097210/sc-allows-bike-taxis-in-karnataka?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 11:14:23 +0000 Scroll Staff
SC allows lighting of lamp atop Thiruparankundram hill as one-time measure https://scroll.in/latest/1097211/sc-allows-lighting-of-lamp-atop-thiruparankundram-hill-as-one-time-measure?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt However, the bench stayed the Madras High Court’s observation that a pillar in question is located on the land that belongs to the Subramania Swamy temple.

The Supreme Court on Friday allowed, as a one-time measure, the lighting of a lamp at a stone pillar on Thiruparankundram hill near Madurai in Tamil Nadu on the Hindu festival of Karthigai Deepam, Bar and Bench reported.

The festival will be celebrated on November 24 this year.

While upholding the Madras High Court order permitting the ritual, the Supreme Court stayed its other observations concerning the nature of the pillar and the ownership of the land on which it stands.

On December 1, High Court judge GR Swaminathan ruled that the stone pillar was a deepathoon, or a structure designed to hold lamps, and that the temple should restore the tradition of lighting the lamp at the site. This came after some temple devotees had sought permission to light a lamp at the stone pillar.

Swaminathan had also held that the practice would not infringe upon the religious rights of the nearby Muslim shrine.

The hillock has the Arulmigu Subramania Swamy temple and the Sikkandar Badhusha dargah.

On January 6, another bench of the High Court upheld Swaminathan’s order, observing that the stone pillar is located on the land that belongs to the Subramania Swamy temple.

However, it said that the lamp should be lit only by members of the temple management and that the public would not be allowed to accompany them.

The Vijay-led Tamil Nadu government had challenged the High Court’s order on June 11.

What the Supreme Court said

On Friday, the Supreme Court held that the lamp may be lit only by a small team from the temple.

The size and composition of the team will be decided by the Madurai district collector in consultation with the temple’s executive officer, the Archaeological Survey of India and the police commissioner, Bar and Bench quoted the court as saying.

The district collector will supervise the arrangements, while the police will provide security, with support from the Central Reserve Police Force if required and feasible, the court added.

The bench also barred public gatherings, processions, demonstrations and the shouting of slogans at the site.

It said that worship at customary sites and lawful access to the nearby dargah and mosque must continue undisturbed.

The court also prohibited excavation, construction and structural alterations at the disputed site.

It clarified that neither the permission nor the ceremony could be treated as proof of an established custom or a right of access, or as a basis for seeking permission in subsequent years.

In December, the previous Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam government, the temple authorities and the dargah management, among others, had moved the Supreme Court against the High Court judgement, raising concerns about law and order, ownership of the site and the nature of the ritual that had been allowed.

Edited by Sneha.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097211/sc-allows-lighting-of-lamp-atop-thiruparankundram-hill-as-one-time-measure?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 10:14:45 +0000 Scroll Staff
Cauvery water dispute: SC rejects Tamil Nadu’s plea for Karnataka to release additional water https://scroll.in/latest/1097208/cauvery-water-dispute-sc-rejects-plea-by-tamil-nadu-for-release-of-additional-water-by-karnataka?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Tamil Nadu had alleged that Karnataka had failed to release its due share of water despite having sufficient storage in its reservoirs.

The Supreme Court on Friday dismissed two applications filed by the Tamil Nadu government seeking directions to Karnataka to release additional water from the Cauvery river, Bar and Bench reported.

The Tamil Nadu government had approached the court seeking the immediate release of 3,500 cusecs of water a day for 15 days from the Kabini and Krishna Raja Sagara reservoirs in Karnataka.

The state contended that the release of 4.5 thousand million cubic feet of water by August 12 was in accordance with a July 30 decision of the Cauvery Water Management Authority.

Tamil Nadu had alleged that Karnataka had failed to release its due share of water despite having sufficient storage in its reservoirs. The Tamil Nadu government had submitted that as of August 3, the combined storage in Karnataka’s four major Cauvery reservoirs – Krishna Raja Sagara, Kabini, Harangi and Hemavathy – was 77.5 thousand million cubic feet. This indicates that the state was in a position to release Tamil Nadu’s share of water.

The state had also contended that recent rainfall in the catchment areas of the Krishna Raja Sagara and Kabini dams meant that it was entitled to 26.9 thousand million cubic feet of water at Biligundlu under the proportional sharing formula.

However, Karnataka had opposed the allegations, maintaining that it was complying with the directions of the Cauvery Water Management Authority.

The Cauvery dispute

The distribution of Cauvery water has been a long-standing dispute between Tamil Nadu and Karnataka. It dates back to two agreements in 1892 and 1924 between the erstwhile Madras Presidency and the Princely State of Mysore.

The Union government set up the Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal in 1990, which delivered its verdict in 2007. The tribunal allocated 419 thousand million cubic feet of water per year to Tamil Nadu and 270 thousand million cubic feet of water to Karnataka.

However, this did not settle the dispute as both Tamil Nadu and Karnataka filed petitions to review the decision.

The Supreme Court in February 2018 asked the Centre to set up the Cauvery Water Management Authority within a month to implement the tribunal’s verdict.

Edited by Sara Varghese.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097208/cauvery-water-dispute-sc-rejects-plea-by-tamil-nadu-for-release-of-additional-water-by-karnataka?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 09:40:50 +0000 Scroll Staff
Indian Air Force’s ‘active’ Rafale count down to 32 from 36, claims directory https://scroll.in/latest/1097200/indian-air-forces-active-rafale-count-down-to-32-from-36-claims-directory?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt In the previous edition released after Operation Sindoor, the World Air Forces list showed India having 35 of the 36 aircraft of the type it had bought.

Thirty-two of the 36 Rafale fighter jets the Indian Air Force had purchased are active, said the 2027 World Air Forces directory released by British aviation publication FlightGlobal.

The previous edition of the directory published in November 2025, after Operation Sindoor, had shown the number of the French-built jet in India’s fleet to be 35.

The directory has also reduced the number of Saab 2000 Erieye airborne early warning aircraft operated by the Pakistani Air Force to seven from nine recorded before the four-day conflict between India and Pakistan in May 2025, The Wire and The Hindu reported.

India’s Ministry of Defence has not yet commented on the data published by FlightGlobal.

However, The Hindu quoted unidentified ministry officials as having questioned the authenticity of the data, saying it had not provided the information.

The assessment was based on data compiled by Cirium, a UK-based aircraft intelligence and fleet tracking firm.

The data does not specify why the aircraft were deemed to be inactive or why the numbers had changed in a year.

Cirium tracks fleet by tail numbers based on public sightings, flight-tracking and open-source data and defence reporting. The tracker can drop aircraft from the “active” list if planes are undergoing long-term depot-level overhaul, structural repair or upgrades without confirmed sightings during a 12-month period, The Wire reported.

An aircraft being counted as inactive does not directly imply that it was lost in combat.

Some of the figures in the directory also appeared inconsistent. The edition published on November 10 lists 263 Su-30MKIs with the Indian Air Force as active, even as it is widely reported to have a fleet of 258 to 260 of these jets.

Air Marshal Narmdeshwar Tiwari (retired), who was the vice air chief during Operation Sindoor, on Thursday said that the claim made in the World Air Forces directory was “patently false” and said that the publication should re-evaluate its sources.

“The same sources gave specific tail numbers, which since have been flying in various exercises including international ones,” he said on social media. “The same sources said that Squadron Leader Shivangi Singh was taken as a PoW [prisoner of war]. We all know how that turned out.”

Operation Sindoor claims and counter claims

Tensions between New Delhi and Islamabad escalated on May 7 when the Indian military carried out strikes – codenamed Operation Sindoor – on what it claimed were terrorist camps in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir.

The strikes were in response to the Pahalgam terror attack, which killed 26 persons in April 2025.

On May 10, the two sides reached an “understanding” to halt firing.

Pakistan has claimed that it shot down Indian fighter jets during air-to-air combat. The claims made by Islamabad have not been independently verified.

India acknowledged suffering aircraft losses during the initial phase of the conflict, but has not disclosed the number of planes lost.

In July 2025, Indian Defence Secretary RK Singh told CNBC-TV18 that it was incorrect to say that multiple Rafale jets of the Indian Air Force were shot down. “You have used the term Rafales in the plural, I can assure you that is absolutely not correct,” the official told the channel.

In July 2025, AP quoted French Air Force chief General Jérôme Bellanger as saying that he had seen evidence pointing to three Indian fighter jet losses: a Rafale, a Russian-made Su-30MKI and a Mirage 2000.

The Mirage 2000 is also a French-made fighter jet, but of an earlier generation.

The Indian Air Force has also claimed that it downed five Pakistan aircraft of the F-16 and JF-17 classes during the conflict. While F-16 jets are manufactured in the US, JF-17 aircraft are Chinese-made.

In August 2025, Amar Preet Singh, the Indian Air Force chief at the time, claimed that one large Pakistani aircraft, which was either an electronic intelligence plane or an airborne early warning system, had also been shot down during the conflict.

This followed the Indian military’s claim on May 12, 2025, two days after the ceasefire, that the Pakistan Air Force had lost “a few” aircraft.

While Islamabad has not commented on losing any of its aircraft, it has acknowledged that several of its airbases were struck by India during the hostilities.

In February, the Union government approved a proposal to buy 114 more Rafales for the Indian Air Force. India is also buying 26 Rafale Marines, an aircraft carrier-borne variant of the fighter jet, for its Navy.

Edited by Nachiket Deuskar and Sara Varghese.


Also read: Why ‘shooting down’ fighter jets has become central to narrative setting


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097200/indian-air-forces-active-rafale-count-down-to-32-from-36-claims-directory?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 08:22:30 +0000 Scroll Staff
First time since Operation Sindoor, Pakistan minister visits India for SCO meeting https://scroll.in/latest/1097203/first-time-since-operation-sindoor-pakistan-minister-visits-india-for-sco-meeting?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt This is the first visit by a Pakistani official in three years and the highest diplomatic engagement between New Delhi and Islamabad since the 2025 conflict.

A Pakistani delegation led by minister Musadik Malik arrived in Delhi on Friday for the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation’s Civilisational Dialogue Forum.

This is the first visit by a Pakistani minister to India in more than three years.

The last such high-level visit was in May 2023, when Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, Pakistan’s foreign minister at the time, travelled ​for a meeting of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation’s foreign ministers.

Malik’s visit also marks the highest level of diplomatic engagement between India and Pakistan since Operation Sindoor. It comes amid continued diplomatic tensions following the four-day conflict between the two countries in May 2025.

Malik is the federal minister for climate change and environmental coordination. He was received at the airport by Pakistani Chargé d’Affaires Saad Warraich, the country’s diplomatic mission said.

India is hosting the first Shanghai Cooperation Organisation’s Civilisational Dialogue Forum from Friday to Sunday at Purana Qila in New Delhi.

“This is a multilateral event within the SCO framework, for which invitations have been extended to all members of the SCO, including Pakistan,” the Ministry of External Affairs said on Friday.

The three-day event aims to celebrate the rich and interconnected civilisational heritage of the region, strengthen people-to-people ties and promote cross-cultural dialogue and cooperation, the prime minister’s office said.

The Shanghai Cooperation Organisation comprises India, Pakistan, China, Russia, Iran and five other countries from the Eurasian region.

The last visit by an Indian minister to Pakistan was by External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar in October 2024. He had represented New Delhi at the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation’s heads of government meeting.

This was also the first time an Indian external affairs minister had visited Pakistan since 2015.

Written by Nachiket Deuskar. Edited by Sara Varghese.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097203/first-time-since-operation-sindoor-pakistan-minister-visits-india-for-sco-meeting?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 07:53:24 +0000 Scroll Staff
US religious freedom panel alleges India is targeting Muslims in SIR https://scroll.in/latest/1097205/us-religious-freedom-panel-alleges-india-is-targeting-muslims-in-sir?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt New Delhi was removing Muslims from the revised voter rolls, ‘calling them foreigners’ and ‘illegally deporting’ them, the organisation alleged.

India has increased its targeting of Muslims ​during the special intensive revision of electoral rolls, a United States panel ‌on religious freedom alleged on Thursday.

The US Commission on International Religious Freedom quoted its head Asif Mahmood as alleging that the Indian government was “targeting Muslim citizens by removing them from voter rolls, calling them ‘foreigners’, and now illegally deporting” them.

“All this as [Union] Home Minister Amit Shah has referred to India’s Muslims as ‘infiltrators’ that must be expelled,” Mahmood said.

On November 2, Shah claimed that three crore of the voters removed from the electoral rolls during the special intensive revision were “Bangladeshi infiltrators”.

The Opposition has been raising concerns about how the voters were being deleted from the electoral rolls, alleging that 13 crore voters had been intentionally removed where the revision has taken place.

The panel also quoted its Commissioner Gene Mills as saying that the Indian government’s “expulsion of its own citizens based on their Muslim faith is a shocking escalation of tactics that target religious minorities”.

The US Department of State should designate India as a “country of particular concern" for its “systematic and egregious” violations of the freedom of religion or belief.

The commission is an independent US government agency that monitors the universal right to freedom of religion and makes policy suggestions. Its suggestions are not binding.

In its 2026 annual report too, the panel had recommended that the state department designate India as a country of particular concern for engaging in “systematic, ongoing, and egregious religious freedom violations”.

The Ministry of External Affairs has not yet responded to the commission’s allegations. But it has previously said that the panel has a “pattern of issuing biased and politically motivated assessments”.

On November 14, the Indian ambassador to the US said that the commission should introspect on its “prejudices” and “stop lecturing others”, after the panel shared a profile of jailed activist Sharjeel Imam on social media.

The panel stated a day earlier that Imam is “a Muslim man detained in India for his religious freedom advocacy”. The activist has been in prison for more than six years in the 2020 Delhi riots conspiracy case, registered under the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act. The trial in the case is yet to begin.

A contentious exercise

In 2025, the first phase of the voter roll revision was conducted in Bihar. It was extended to 12 states and Union Territories in the second phase in late 2025 and the first half of 2026. The third phase of the exercise, covering 19 states and Union Territories, is underway.

Since the exercise began, concerns have been raised that the revision could eliminate genuine voters from the rolls and even shape electoral outcomes, as Scroll has reported.

In May, the Supreme Court upheld the legality of the revision. But it said that the exercise does not mean that the Election Commission can decide on whether the person is an Indian citizen.

Despite this, Bharatiya Janata Party-ruled states have cited the SIR to deny ration cards to those who have been eliminated from the rolls. In some cases, the police have denied permission for their passports to be renewed.

Since October 2, nationwide protests have been held calling for the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar over concerns about the functioning of the Election Commission and the alleged irregularities in how the voter roll is being revised.

Written by Nachiket Deuskar. Edited by Sara Varghese.



]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097205/us-religious-freedom-panel-alleges-india-is-targeting-muslims-in-sir?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 06:44:23 +0000 Scroll Staff
Mumbai: Dadar metro stop, not rail station, to be renamed Chaityabhoomi, clarifies CM https://scroll.in/latest/1097174/mumbai-dadar-railway-station-to-be-renamed-chaityabhoomi?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The BJP-led Maharashtra government has deleted its statements from Wednesday about renaming the Dadar railway station.

Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis on Thursday clarified that the Dadar metro station in Mumbai would be renamed Chaityabhoomi, PTI reported.

On Wednesday, the Bharatiya Janata Party-led Maharashtra government stated that it had given its in-principle approval to rename the Dadar railway station to Chaityabhoomi.

The Maharashtra Directorate General of Information and Public Relations has since deleted its statement posted on social media.

The announcement was made ahead of Mahaparinirvan Day on December 6, which marks the death anniversary of BR Ambedkar. Chaityabhoomi is the cremation site and memorial for Ambedkar in Dadar.

The decision to rename the station will be formalised during the Winter Session of the state Legislature, which will begin on December 7.

Fadnavis had earlier also said that additional funding would be provided to expedite the work on the Ambedkar memorial at Indu Mill near Chaityabhoomi.

The chief minister had directed the authorities to ban sit-in protests, demonstrations and marches near Chaityabhoomi, saying that visitors should not face inconvenience.

Fifteen lakh persons were expected to visit the site and Shivaji Park on December 6, the state public relations department said on Wednesday.

In 2024, the state government gave its in-principle approval to rename eight railway stations in Mumbai.

Mumbai Central station was to be renamed Nana Jagannath Shankarsheth station. Curry Road was to be renamed Lalbaug, Sandhurst Road was to be Dongri. In addition, Marine Lines was to be rechristened Mumbadevi and Charni Roadwas to be called Girgaon.

Cotton Green was to be renamed Kalachowki, Dockyard as Mazgaon and King’s Circle as Tirthankar Parswanath.

Written by Abeer Khan. Edited by Nachiket Deuskar, Tanya Shrivastava and Sneha.

Corrections and clarifications: This story was updated to quote the chief minister as clarifying that the metro station in Dadar, not the railway station, will be renamed, and to say that the government deleted its earlier statement.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097174/mumbai-dadar-railway-station-to-be-renamed-chaityabhoomi?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 06:23:53 +0000 Scroll Staff
Great Nicobar port could risk the unique genetic diversity of Galathea Bay’s leatherback turtles https://scroll.in/article/1096998/great-nicobar-port-could-erase-galathea-bays-leatherback-turtles-and-their-unique-genetic-diversity?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Leatherbacks as a whole have poor gene diversity which affects their survival and adaptation, making any additional diversity precious.

Last winter, female leatherbacks heaved themselves onto a beach bordering Galathea Bay on Great Nicobar Island to dig and lay eggs in 869 nests, according to data from the Andaman and Nicobar Forest Department obtained through the Right to Information Act. That is the highest number of leatherback nests recorded on any beach in the Indian Ocean in this year’s nesting season, ending in March.

In further good news, the numbers of leatherback nests not only on Galathea but also on the South Bay and West Bay beaches of Little Andaman Island have been going up in recent years, the data shows. Andaman and Nicobar is “the stronghold” of the Northeastern Indian Ocean leatherback population, said a researcher who did not wish to be named. “The population, being left alone, is thriving and likely overflowing” onto other beaches in the neighbourhood.

“It’s common sense that Galathea is the epicentre of that nesting population,” says Hiltrud Cordes of the Turtle Foundation, which works with communities in Indonesia to protect marine turtles. That is, although leatherbacks in the Northeastern Indian Ocean also nest on other beaches of Andaman and Nicobar and on Sumatra, Galathea Bay in Great Nicobar Island shelters the most nests of all sites that have been consistently monitored. The new nesting data indicate that Galathea alone hosts about 175 or more leatherback mothers per year, more than estimated for all of Sumatra or the Andamans.

Underscoring the significance of Galathea, the leatherbacks nesting there also have comparatively high genetic diversity, according to a study conducted in the winter of 2001-2002. Marine biologists Kartik Shanker and BC Choudhury, then at the Wildlife Institute of India, Dehradun, took tiny amounts of blood and tissue from more than 100 leatherback turtles nesting at Galathea. They then worked with the Centre for Cellular and Molecular Biology, Hyderabad, to examine the genetic material of the mitochondria, called mtDNA, in these samples.

Mitochondria are passed from mother to offspring; so capturing mtDNA enables scientists to trace the turtles’ maternal line of descent. “We wanted to create a baseline,” says Choudhury. They detected four distinct haplotypes – labelled A, D, E, and I – which are segments of genes that have passed intact through generations. The number of haplotypes provide a rough measure of genetic diversity, which tends to be higher for populations that are older in evolutionary terms.

Their study established that the genetic diversity of Galathea’s leatherbacks was among the highest measured anywhere in the world at that time. Back then, only the leatherbacks nesting on Terrengganu beach in Malaysia had been found to also have four haplotypes: A, D, E and H.

In 2015, Shanker, along with Peter H Dutton, a marine biologist who has studied the genetics of leatherbacks worldwide, pulled together the available data to postulate that the world’s leatherbacks descended from a few that had survived the ice ages by nesting on beaches of the Sundaland biodiversity hotspot, which includes Great Nicobar Island. Modern-day leatherbacks, Dermochelys coriacea, have low genetic diversity overall, perhaps reflecting the population “bottleneck” about a million years ago, the authors speculated.

That limited diversity makes some conservationists worry about the capacity of these marine animals to adapt to intensifying challenges such as climate change. “Diversity is the raw material upon which adaptation works,” says Shanker, who is now at the Indian Institute of Science and a founder of Dakshin Foundation, which works on ecosystem health and human wellbeing in coastal and marine ecosystems.

“If you have two populations to conserve, and you could only pick one, you want to pick the one with greater diversity because that greater diversity has the raw material for the adaptation or the evolution of that lineage.”

However, the stability of Great Nicobar’s leatherback population is threatened by a massive development project along the Island’s southern and eastern coasts, including the construction of an international container transshipment terminal port on Galathea Bay.

Mariners from deep time

In 2026, Wesley D Colombo of the Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais in Brazil and his colleagues integrated the world’s data on leatherback mtDNA to construct a family tree locating the primordial mother of all modern leatherbacks as having lived almost five million years ago in the Pacific Ocean. Her descendants spread to the Indian Ocean roughly three million years ago and to the Atlantic twice – about 1.7 million years ago and again, about a million years ago or less.

Leatherback turtles are “the closest thing we have to a living dinosaur,” writes marine biologist Carl Safina in his book Voyage of the Turtle. Their family, Dermochelydae, has been cruising the planet’s oceans for more than 100 million years – since when our own ancestors resembled shrews as puny as mice, and the Indian subcontinent was a triangular island that had just broken off the Gondwana supercontinent.

With the ability to traverse entire ocean basins, dive to depths that would crush humans in fractions of a second, and tolerate close-to-freezing temperatures, leatherbacks survived the great extinction event 66 million years ago that killed off other dinosaurs.

But only one species of leatherback, Dermochelys coriacea, made it through the ice ages, between 2.8 million and 700,000 years ago. By then, the Indian continental plate had hit the Eurasian, the Indian Ocean had expanded, and the cluster of small islands that had emerged between the Indian and the Pacific oceans, where several tectonic plates collided and folded, provided nesting beaches. Among these havens were the Andaman and Nicobar Islands.

New studies from other islands of the Indo-Pacific region are finding even higher diversity than was detected on Great Nicobar, however, thanks to advances in research and sustained interest in leatherback genetics. Researchers have found 11 haplotypes on Jeen Yessa (formerly Jamursba Medi) beach in West Papua, for instance. And on Sumatra, biologists have discovered eight haplotypes: D, E, I, and several variants of A, as well as an entirely new haplotype not seen anywhere else in the world.

Maslim As-singkily, a conservation scientist at the Wageningen University and Research in the Netherlands, says the discovery of higher genetic diversity on Sumatra isn’t surprising. “There aren’t a lot of studies for the Indian Ocean population. So, there will be new information when you study it.”

As-singkily and his co-authors argue that the leatherbacks nesting on Sumatra are genetically distinct enough to be managed separately from the Northeast Indian Ocean population. “High haplotype diversity is often associated with regions that have experienced historical connectivity and may act as critical genetic reservoirs for migratory species, making Sumatra a key site for maintaining the species’ genetic health and long-term resilience,” they write.

According to Shanker, the Sumatran population only looks more genetically diverse than the Andaman and Nicobar ones because As-singkily and others sequenced longer segments of mtDNA. “It’s the same one as in Great Nicobar,” he emphasises. The 2001 Galathea study had examined snippets of mitochondrial DNA of less than 400 base pairs (molecular units that are strung together to make up DNA), whereas recent studies use longer lengths of mitochondrial DNA, of close to 800 base pairs.

There are other indications that leatherbacks from Sumatra and Great Nicobar are related. In January 2023, a leatherback tagged on Galathea also nested in Along beach in Sumatra 10 days later, according to Cordes. And several of the leatherbacks tagged with satellite transmitters on Little Andaman followed the Sumatran coastline on their way toward Australian waters, notes Shanker.

As-singkily, on the other hand, believes that the Andaman and Nicobar leatherbacks are more closely related to those that had once nested on Terrenganu, Malaysia, based on discussions with fisherfolk who suggest that the turtles from the Indian Ocean also use Malacca Strait to travel eastward to the South China Sea. But this matter cannot be resolved by further genetic studies of Terengganu’s leatherbacks since that population is now all but extinct.

A single female delighted conservationists by returning to nest three times in Malaysia this past September, after a complete absence of turtle nesting for nine years. According to marine biologist Nicolas Pilcher of Save Our Seas Foundation, a combination of excessive egg collection, deaths by drowning in offshore fishing nets, and unscientific hatchery management virtually extirpated Terengganu’s population that had once nested in the thousands – a reminder of how vulnerable leatherbacks are to human activity on and near a key nesting beach.

Information black hole

No new genetic data from the Andaman and Nicobar Islands has emerged since that pioneering work, done a quarter century ago. The tsunami of 2004 destroyed the beach, and although the beaches of Great Nicobar have since reformed and the leatherbacks have returned, the research focus has shifted to Little Andaman for logistical and safety reasons, says Shanker.

Also deterring genetics research on leatherbacks is the arduous process of getting permission from the Indian Government to take tissue samples, says Chowdhury. Leatherback turtles are a Schedule I species with the highest level of protection under the Indian Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972. “Most often, by the time your grant period is over, all this bureaucratic procedure is still not over, and your time is gone,” he says. Even if permission is granted, “they will add about 20 different clauses. You cannot collect blood samples from more than five individuals and so on. Sometimes the sample size would be so low that it’s not even worth trying to do any work,” he adds.

A team led by Shanker at Dakshin Foundation does have tissue samples from leatherbacks nesting on Little Andaman, collected over the last 15 years, however. Thus far, Dakshin researchers have sequenced shorter lengths of mtDNA from nine leatherbacks on West Bay beach, finding three haplotypes — A, E and I. Given the limited number of leatherbacks studied, that represents relatively high diversity, but the sample size is too small to be statistically meaningful. The team is currently studying longer sequences of base pairs, which are required to compare the genetic diversity of Little Andaman leatherbacks with those nesting on Sumatra and elsewhere in the world.

The genetic profile of Great Nicobar’s leatherbacks is likely to be very similar to that of Little Andaman leatherbacks, given that a leatherback tagged on Little Andaman in 2014 reportedly turned up on Galathea in 2021. But the mtDNA haplotypes on these two islands may not be identical. As-singkily reports that different beaches on Sumatra turned up different haplotypes, with the brand-new haplotype being found only in a single leatherback.

A state-of-the-art genetic study at Galathea, examining longer haplotype sequences over several nesting seasons, could well yield far greater diversity than measured in the 2001 study. Such a study being undertaken at this time appears unlikely, however, given that the container terminal planned at Galathea Bay could render the nesting beach inaccessible to marine turtles.

All research on Great Nicobar’s multitude of species is currently being conducted by government-affiliated departments or agencies. That recent nesting data for Great Nicobar had to be obtained through a Right to Information request, whereas earlier surveys were published in the scientific literature, offers a glimpse of the secrecy shrouding information about wildlife on the island.

As survivors from deep time, leatherbacks are often described as resilient. But unlike whales and dolphins, which also descend from an ancestor that originally lived on land, marine turtles never evolved a way to have their offspring in the water. “Their last trace of land-oriented existence — the females’ need to return to shore to lay eggs – is their Achilles’ heel,” writes Safina in Voyage.

Leatherbacks may have survived threats that killed off other dinosaurs, but their need to return, not only to land but to the beach of their birth to perpetuate their life cycle “is a hallmark of vulnerability, not resilience,” Safina added in an interview.

That vulnerability is about to be tested in an experiment that experts say has never been tried before — the loss of a major nesting beach, alongside massive ship traffic, and likely increased fishing as a projected 325,000 newcomers to Great Nicobar seek sustenance. “What happens when that stronghold breaks?” asked the researcher who wished to remain anonymous. “That’s the million-dollar question that all of us would not like to test.”

This article was first published on Mongabay.

]]>
https://scroll.in/article/1096998/great-nicobar-port-could-erase-galathea-bays-leatherback-turtles-and-their-unique-genetic-diversity?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 06:04:11 +0000 Madhusree Mukerjee
As another cyclone hits eastern coast, India must work on protecting livelihoods – not just lives https://scroll.in/article/1097195/as-third-cyclone-in-two-months-hits-eastern-coast-india-must-work-on-protecting-livelihoods?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The focus must shift to cash transfers to protect property and reduce damage.

Andhra Pradesh is bracing for yet another cyclone, Akvan, even as it deals with the damage left by Arnab and Murasu at the end of October.

Before Cyclone Arnab made landfall on India’s east coast, the authorities had evacuated more than 1.8 lakh people in Andhra Pradesh and Odisha. It’s clear that India has learnt to move people out of harm’s way.

But now, it should focus on releasing money efficiently for them to protect what they leave behind. Within days of Arnab and Murasu striking, Andhra Pradesh sought more than Rs 4,500 crore in immediate central assistance.

Extreme cyclone events have increased by three times in Odisha and doubled in Andhra Pradesh over the last five decades due to climate change, an analysis by the Council on Energy, Environment and Water shows. At the same time, India has made remarkable progress in forecasting cyclones and evacuating exposed communities.

In Odisha, cyclone deaths fell from nearly 10,000 in the 1999 super cyclone to fewer than 100 in Phailin in 2013 and Fani in 2019. A million people were moved to safety each time. The 2023 study by the Council on Energy, Environment and Water found that cyclone warnings now cover 100% of the populations exposed to cyclones.

But an early warning is only the first step: districts must have the resources to act on the situation that follows.

What does this mean for the residents most impacted? Leaving home could mean losing daily wages, while reaching a shelter may require transport. Electricity restoration too depends on having repair crews, equipment and funds ready.

For fishers, securing their boats and nets protects the household’s only source of income. For farmers, an approaching cyclone raises difficult choices about harvesting standing crops, moving livestock to safety and safeguarding equipment.

Andhra Pradesh estimates that Cyclone Murasu damaged crops across 1.44 lakh hectares, affecting more than 1.86 lakh farmers. Agricultural losses amounted to Rs 875 crore, while damage to horticulture was estimated at Rs 337 crore.

India must now work to make a portion of its state disaster response funding available to district administrations before a cyclone makes landfall, triggered by forecasts and tied to specific actions pre-defined by the state.

Forecast-based or anticipatory financing could offer a way forward. It refers to fund disbursal based on forecasts that cross agreed upon thresholds, enabling authorities to take specific actions before a hazard strikes.

In Bangladesh, for example, research on anticipatory cash transfers ahead of floods found that among recipient households it improved access to food and reduced reliance on high-interest debt to cope with the immediate impacts of flooding.

India could adapt this approach by using India Meteorological Department forecasts to prepare defined triggers, linking them with clear responsibilities and district-level action plans.

Parametric insurance, which pays out when specific conditions such as wind speed thresholds are met, could complement these cash transfers. India has already begun testing this approach: Nagaland received a payout of over Rs 1 crore under its extreme-rainfall insurance scheme in 2025.

Similarly, a pilot scheme in Cuddalore, Tamil Nadu, is extending cyclone-linked parametric insurance to 2,500 households, demonstrating how vulnerable households can access funds without waiting for individual damage assessments.

The Sixteenth Finance Commission’s recent recommendation to allocate Rs 204,401 crore for state disaster response and mitigation funds over 2026-’31 offers an institutional opportunity to achieve this. The Ministry of Home Affairs has issued the corresponding operational guidelines for release and access of the State Disaster Response Fund and National Disaster Response Fund.

The priority now remains to translate these funding arrangements into timely, locally targeted action. Three critical shifts could help achieve this.

First, release money before a cyclone makes landfall. The Ministry of Home Affairs, through the National and State Disaster Management Authorities, must operationalise anticipatory financing through clear protocols linked to existing disaster management funds under the 16th Finance Commission.

They should specify pre-financing guidelines demarcating the forecast thresholds or triggers, eligible actions, responsible officers and timelines for releasing these funds.

Eligible actions could include arranging transport to shelters, especially for the elderly and persons with disabilities, advance cash or food coupons, increased assistance to secure boats and nets, early harvesting where feasible, and livestock protections. Funds must be accessible within hours of a trigger, not only after losses are documented.

Second, direct funds where risk is highest and need is greatest. Every Indian coastal district must have hyperlocal risk assessments, developed with panchayats, and local communities such as fishing cooperatives and women’s groups, to identify exposed households, farmlands, power lines, roads and health facilities, and assign each priority action a budget and responsible agency. These could be further linked to identify most vulnerable households and help trigger forecast-based finance much more accurately.

Third, measure what should be protected. After each cyclone, states should track the time households and businesses take to resume work, disaggregated by gender, income, occupation, disability and location. These findings should inform future funding triggers and safer reconstruction. This will also help states identify the tangible outcomes of targeted and anticipated funds.

Institutional reform has transformed disaster preparedness. India’s next benchmark should be fiscal: ensuring that money reaches people and frontline agencies while there is time to protect livelihoods, rather than after the damage has been counted.

Shreya Wadhawan is Programme Lead and Vishwas Chitale is Fellow at the Council on Energy, Environment and Water. Views are personal.

]]>
https://scroll.in/article/1097195/as-third-cyclone-in-two-months-hits-eastern-coast-india-must-work-on-protecting-livelihoods?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 05:39:28 +0000 Shreya Wadhawan
Impeachment proceedings unnecessary after resignation: Justice Varma tells Lok Sabha https://scroll.in/latest/1097202/impeachment-proceedings-unnecessary-after-resignation-justice-varma-tells-lok-sabha?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Yashwant Varma said that his resignation as a judge should not be construed as an admission of the allegations against him in the unaccounted cash row.

Justice Yashwant Varma, who is facing an inquiry into an unaccounted cash row, has contended that the proceedings to impeach him as a High Court judge have become infructuous and cannot continue as he has resigned, PTI reported on Thursday.

The unaccounted cash had been recovered at Varma’s official residence in Delhi when emergency services responded to a fire there on March 14, 2025. He was a judge at the Delhi High Court at the time.

The judge said that he was in Bhopal when the incident occurred and claimed that the cash did not belong to him or his family.

The controversy prompted his transfer to the Allahabad High Court. He resigned from his post in April, more than two months after Parliament’s process to impeach the judge began.

In a letter to the Lok Sabha secretary general on September 10, Varma said that any attempt to remove him from office would be unconstitutional, PTI reported. The letter was shared with MPs on Thursday.

He was responding to the report submitted on August 12 by an inquiry committee set up by Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla.

Varma reiterated that he was innocent of the allegations against him, including the suggestion that he possessed “ill-gotten funds”, Deccan Herald reported.

He said that his resignation as a judge should not be construed as an admission of the allegations against him.

The committee had found Varma guilty, saying that all the charges framed against him had been proved. It said that “unexplained bundles of Rs 500” had been recovered from the Delhi residence and that the former judge had given misleading explanations about it.

The committee noted that the explanations given by Varma were “evasive and unsatisfactory when tested against the evidence of independent official witnesses”.

The three-member committee had been formed by Birla in August 2025. It was headed by Supreme Court judge Justice Aravind Kumar and comprised former Bombay High Court Chief Justice Shree Chandrasekhar and advocate BV Acharya.

In January, the Supreme Court rejected Varma’s petition challenging the legality of the inquiry committee.

Days after the cash was recovered, the Supreme Court had also set up a three-member committee to look into the allegations.

On March 22, 2025, the court released a report, including a video and three photographs, showing bundles of notes that were allegedly recovered from the judge’s home.

As Varma had declined to voluntarily retire or resign, Sanjiv Khanna, who was the chief justice of India at the time, sent the final inquiry committee report on the incident to the president and the prime minister.

The committee, in its report, had concluded that there was “sufficient substance” in the charges against Varma. The report dated May 3, 2025, held that the judge’s misconduct was “serious enough to call for initiation of proceedings for removal”.

Edited by Sara Varghese.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097202/impeachment-proceedings-unnecessary-after-resignation-justice-varma-tells-lok-sabha?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 04:11:37 +0000 Scroll Staff
How some Indian National Army recruits in Singapore worked to undermine Japan during WWII https://scroll.in/article/1081165/how-some-indian-national-army-recruits-in-singapore-worked-to-undermine-japan-during-wwii?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt They believed that enlisting Japan’s help to gain independence in India was risky.

World War II spread from Europe to Asia December 1941 when Japan launched its own Blitzkrieg. This surprising move had an influence on the Indian freedom struggle.

Soon after Japan captured Singapore in February 1942, the Indian National Army was recruited from the thousands of Indian army men who had been part of the British-led Allied army defending Singapore and had become prisoners of war.

Supported by Japan, the goal of the Indian National Army was to free India of British rule.

Indian history textbooks are filled with stories of the Indian National Army. Less well known, though, is that there was an active anti-Japanese resistance embedded within the organisation. They believed that seeking Japan’s help for Indian independence was fraught with risk and tried to sabotage the movement from within. This took many forms.

In mid-1942, a long-range radio station was started by Japan and Indian nationalists to broadcast anti-British propaganda to India. It was based in Singapore’s tallest building – the Cathay cinema. A daily programme of broadcasts explained the need for independence, elaborated on the strength of the Indian National Army and underscored that Japanese support for the movement was genuine. It encouraged Indians to unite and rise against the British.

Its routine would be familiar to some media houses today. A morning meeting was held by the Japanese, who were in charge, to decide the focus and news for the day. A script was written in English and given to the broadcasters, who would read them out in various Indian languages.

The Japanese would be listening but were not been able to understand everyone. So some made their own changes.

One of the features was to read out messages from Indian POWs in Singapore to their families in India, telling them that they were alive and well. The Japanese asked the announcers to add that they were very happy under Japan. Some resisted this.

In August 1942, one of the POWs asked to do this was Havildar Shikoh, of the Royal Indian Army Service Corps. A Muslim from Sri Lanka, he had grown up in Lucknow, was 5-foot 8, broad-faced, of medium build and 22 years old. When the station heard his “deep resonant voice, singularly beautiful”, he was asked to join as a regular.

Staunchly anti-Japanese, he flatly refused. But after discussing the matters with some seniors, Shikoh decided to take the plunge.

His goal was to steal or read uncensored documents and pass the information on to the wider resistance network of anti-Japanese POWs and civilians. Soon, he became the voice of Awaz-e-Islam, one of the daily broadcasts.

Using his access within the station, he made a duplicate key to the office of the Japanese news censor. A post-war assessment report says that he then “engaged in the very dangerous occupation of extracting information from the locked drawer of the Japanese director’s desk”.

Once, Shikoh was seen by a fellow India taking papers out. Fortunately for him only reprimanded.

In clandestine meetings with the wider network, he would pass on the documents.

In another close shave, Shikoh was almost caught at the Luna Café.

As Shikoh continued reading out messages from POWs to their family in India, he embedded coded references that sounded outwardly innocent, but the family would understand what they really meant.

In 1944, Shikoh was joined by Upper Division Clerk Inayatullah Mark of the Indian Army Corps of Clerks. A Protestant from Montgomery, Punjab, 26-year-old Mark was thin, 5-foot, 9, a graduate in History and Economics.

After Singapore’s surrender to the Japanese in February 1942, Mark slipped into the city, mingled and lived amongst the thousands of Indians civilians there, till he was caught in August that year. He served as a supply officer in an Indian National Army regiment till March 1944, when he was posted as an English broadcaster at the radio station due to his sonorous voice.

Mark too was anti-Japanese. But his activities had already attracted attention. As a result, his Chinese fiancé Grace Tan had been interrogated about him. Though Mark could not take the same risks as Shikoh, the two men worked well together, feeding the resistance with uncensored news.

In early 1945, Mark was posted to the Indian National Army in Ipoh, Malaysia. By now Shikoh had come under suspicion too, but was able to obtain 15 days leave in April and headed there. He was followed by an Indian spy who worked for the Japanese secret police, the Kempetai, who reported back regularly to his superiors in Singapore.

Fortunately for Shikoh, he was able to remain a step ahead because the spy’s updates made by telephone from a restaurant were overheard by a waitress also part of the anti-Japanese network. She relayed them to Mark, with whom Shikoh was staying.

Arrangements were made and Shikoh joined anti-Japanese guerillas nearby. With them he focused on fighting Japanese propaganda trying to drive a wedge between the ethnic groups in Malaya – Muslim Malays, Chinese and Hindu Indians.

In August 1945, Shikoh started working with Force 136, which consisted of Britons and locals – Malays, Chinese and Indians – many trained in India, to sabotage the Japanese war effort.

Soon after, the war ended and in September 1945, Malaya was liberated by Indian troops. When Shikoh returned to India after the war is not clear. Mark probably stayed back in Singapore with Grace, by then his wife.

Like resistance networks across the world during the war, people of similar views in Singapore banded together. Shikoh and Mark were able to distribute uncensored news – a commodity as useful and as scarce as food – within the anti-Japanese network. For hundreds who were discovered, it meant immediate torture and death. This fear hung over the network every day, so what they did was very brave.

Gautam Hazarika is a Singapore-based author whose book on the Indian Army Prisoners of World War II is being published by Penguin India and Pen & Sword UK later this year. He can be contacted at ghazarika70@yahoo.com.sg.

Corrections & Clarifications: This article has been updated to reflect the fact that Inayatullah Mark worked in the Indian Army Corps of Clerks.

]]>
https://scroll.in/article/1081165/how-some-indian-national-army-recruits-in-singapore-worked-to-undermine-japan-during-wwii?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Fri, 20 Nov 2026 03:12:59 +0000 Gautam Hazarika
Malaysia to end visa-free entry for Indians from next year https://scroll.in/latest/1097197/malaysia-to-end-visa-free-entry-for-indians-from-next-year?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt In September, the High Commission of India in Kuala Lumpur advised Indians travelling to Malaysia on tourist visas against taking up jobs in the country.

Malaysia’s Immigration Department stated on Tuesday that the 30-day visa exemption facility available to Indians will end on December 31.

In 2023, Malaysia granted Indian citizens a 30-day visa exemption, requiring them only to register for the Malaysia Digital Arrival Card within three days before their arrival. The facility was extended till 2026.

Indians entering Malaysia from January 1 will be required to obtain a valid visa prior to their arrival.

Visa applications can be submitted through the MyVISA portal from December 1, the department said. It added that visa processing fees would be non-refundable, irrespective of the outcome of the application, any changes in policy or subsequent changes to travel plans.

It also advised visitors to secure medical insurance covering their entire stay in Malaysia, adding that non-residents are required to pay for medical treatment and other healthcare services and bear all associated expenses.

In September, the High Commission of India in Kuala Lumpur advised Indians travelling to Malaysia on tourist visas against taking up employment in the country.

“There is a noticeable increase in Indian nationals arriving in Malaysia using the 30-day visa-free facility, to seek employment,” the High Commission had said in a social media post. “Many Indian nationals are misled by unscrupulous agents with false job promises, leading to overstay, illegal status, exploitation, detention and legal action.”

It said that the visa-free entry facility allows Indian passport holders to stay in Malaysia for up to 30 days only for tourism and social visits. Taking up employment in the country amounted to “a clear violation of immigration rules”,

Edited by Sneha.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097197/malaysia-to-end-visa-free-entry-for-indians-from-next-year?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Thu, 19 Nov 2026 14:56:15 +0000 Scroll Staff
Rush Hour: Rahul Gandhi says Congress won’t boycott polls, EPFO changes withdrawal rules and more https://scroll.in/latest/1097194/rush-hour-rahul-gandhi-says-congress-wont-boycott-polls-epfo-changes-withdrawal-rules-and-more?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Become a Scroll member to get Rush Hour – a wrap of the day’s important stories delivered straight to your inbox every evening.

Could your home be at risk from rising seas? Scroll is investigating coastal flooding in Mumbai and Kolkata, mapping vulnerable areas and examining whether developers and the authorities are accounting for the risks. Support this investigation and help us make this reporting possible. Fund the project here.


Congress leader Rahul Gandhi said that his party would never boycott elections but rather face electoral losses until voters realise that the system has been “fully demolished”. “Indian democracy is sacred,” Gandhi said at an event at the University of Chicago.

A day earlier, Gandhi had said that his party was in a “very good position” ahead of the Uttar Pradesh polls since the Congress has an alliance. He said, however, that the “big question over the vote chori [vote theft] business remains”.

However, he had added that “it’s going to become more and more difficult to get away with rigging elections”. Read on.

Why Opposition parties have not boycotted elections despite alleging polls are rigged, explains Nachiket Deuskar


The International Court of Justice ruled that Myanmar committed acts of genocide against the Rohingya, an ethnic minority group. Myanmar’s security forces engaged in “indiscriminate killings, separation and execution of men, sexual violence, and the deliberate burning of Rohingya homes” in certain locations, said the court.

The estimate that 10,000 Rohingya were “violently killed” in 2017 clearance operations was “supported by the evidence”, it added.

The ruling is being viewed as setting a legal benchmark for the genocide case brought by South Africa against Israel over its war on Gaza. Read on.


The Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation has restored an earlier rule that allowed members to claim final settlement of their corpus after two months of unemployment. The move reverses the change made in October 2025, which had extended the waiting period to 12 months.

The minimum period for final pension withdrawal will remain 36 months.

The social security body has also approved a systematic withdrawal plan that will enable members to convert their retirement savings into a “ stable and predictable stream”. It has cut the minimum balance requirement in the provident fund account to 10% from 25%. Read on.


The Supreme Court said that the Election Commission has limited powers against booth level agents accused of filing fraudulent Form 7 applications to seek deletion of voters from electoral rolls. Form 7 is used to object to the inclusion of a name or seek the deletion of an existing name from the electoral roll.

It also directed the Election Commission and Delhi chief electoral officer to verify a complaint submitted by Congress leader Ali Mehdi alleging that false Form 7 applications were filed in northeastern Delhi’s Mustafabad. Read on.

Follow Scroll’s coverage of the special intensive revision of electoral rolls here.


The Supreme Court upheld the interim bail granted to Samajwadi Party leader Azam Khan in a money laundering case. It also noted that the Allahabad High Court’s views in granting the bail would not influence the final decision in the matter.

The High Court had observed that the circumstances of the case and the SP leader’s arrest by the Enforcement Directorate showed the “motivated and mala fide nature” of the proceedings. Read on.


If you haven’t already, sign up for our Daily Brief newsletter.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097194/rush-hour-rahul-gandhi-says-congress-wont-boycott-polls-epfo-changes-withdrawal-rules-and-more?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Thu, 19 Nov 2026 14:19:12 +0000 Scroll Staff
FDA suspends licences of nine Mumbai restaurants for food safety violations https://scroll.in/latest/1097193/fda-suspends-licences-of-nine-mumbai-restaurants-for-food-safety-violations?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Five persons were arrested for dealing in banned products, including paan masala, worth Rs 1.68 lakh.

The Maharashtra Food and Drugs Administration on Tuesday suspended the licences of nine restaurants in Mumbai and seized food stock worth Rs 1.2 crore after finding “serious violations of safety and hygiene regulations”.

The establishments in Mumbai whose licenses were suspended are Naturals Ice Cream, Cafe Ideal, Bayroute, Miyan Kababs, Chetana Restaurant, Shreeyog Restaurant, Gupta Fruit Juice Centre, Prakash Dosa and Saurabh Hotels.

Across the state, five persons were arrested for dealing in banned products, including paan masala, worth Rs 1.6 lakh.

The food safety body said that during inspections, it found open bags of wet waste overflowing near the food preparation counter at Cafe Ideal in Colaba. Raw and cooked non-vegetarian food were also stored together without covers, it added.

At Chetana Restaurant in Kala Ghoda, inspectors found food stored in non-food-grade containers on rusted racks, read the FDA statement.

It said that at Miyan Kababs in Fort, officials spotted a live cockroach on a menu card placed on a customer’s table, along with flies on the premises. Raw marinated kebabs were also found stored above cooked kebabs, stated the food safety authority.

At Naturals Ice Cream in Churchgate, inspectors found uncovered ice cream stored in a dirty freezer. The counter was dusty and had flies, while some products lacked manufacturing and expiry date labels. Food items were also stored alongside non-food items, including gloves and mobile phone chargers.

Inspectors found rodent activity and flies entering through openings without mesh at Bayroute in Cuffe Parade. Desserts and ice cream were stored in a rusted chiller. Officials also found three toilets near the dessert preparation room and an open drain beneath the utensil rack.

At Shreeyog Restaurant in Fort, food items were placed directly on the floor near garbage and uncovered dustbins. Officials found flies in the kitchen as the rear door lacked an insect-proof mesh.

The department also suspended the licences of three food establishments in Thane for unhygienic food storage and lack of pest control. Businesses of six food vendors were shut down in Pune for operating without valid Food Safety and Standards Authority of India licences.

The action comes amid a statewide drive by the department against eateries and other establishments that allegedly violate food safety norms.

Written by Anamika Pathak. Edited by Sneha.


Also read: How a bureaucrat has forced Maharashtra’s eateries and other food businesses to clean up their act


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097193/fda-suspends-licences-of-nine-mumbai-restaurants-for-food-safety-violations?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Thu, 19 Nov 2026 14:04:31 +0000 Scroll Staff
Rahul Gandhi says Congress won’t boycott elections, doesn’t ‘want to end Indian democracy’ https://scroll.in/latest/1097192/rahul-gandhi-says-congress-wont-boycott-elections-dont-want-to-end-indian-democracy?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The Opposition leader said his party was in ‘very good position’ ahead of UP polls, but the ‘big question over the vote chori [vote theft] business remains’.

Congress leader Rahul Gandhi on Wednesday said that his party would never boycott elections but rather face electoral losses until voters realise that the system has been “fully demolished”, PTI reported.

“Indian democracy is sacred,” Gandhi said during an event at the University of Chicago. “If we say that we aren’t going to contest elections, we end Indian democracy that minute.”

He added that the Congress does not “want to end the structure of Indian democracy”.

A day earlier, Gandhi had said that his party was in a “very good position” ahead of the Uttar Pradesh polls since the Congress has an alliance. The Assembly elections in the state are expected to be held early next year.

During an interaction at Columbia University in New York, Gandhi said on Tuesday that the “big question over the vote chori [vote theft] business remains”.

However, he had added “it’s going to become more and more difficult to get away with rigging elections”.

On September 25, Abhijeet Dipke, the founder of the Cockroach Janta Party political campaign, had called on Opposition parties to boycott polls if they do not trust the Election Commission to hold free and fair polls.

Dipke contended that this was a logical inconsistency: why are they participating in exercises they contend are rigged? It is merely for their “political survival”, he claimed.

Dipke’s comments came two days after The Indian Express reported that Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi had formally objected 14 times in 10 months to decisions related to the special intensive revision, saying some had been taken without their knowledge.

Since October 2, nationwide protests have been held calling for the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar over concerns about the functioning of the Election Commission and the alleged irregularities in the electoral process.

Edited by Tanya Shrivastava.


Also read:


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097192/rahul-gandhi-says-congress-wont-boycott-elections-dont-want-to-end-indian-democracy?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Thu, 19 Nov 2026 11:51:45 +0000 Scroll Staff
Bengal minister says those criticising police killing accused in gunfights should ‘go to Bangladesh’ https://scroll.in/latest/1097176/go-to-bangladesh-bengal-minister-dismisses-criticism-of-killings-in-police-gunfights?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt There have been at least five such deaths since the Bharatiya Janata Party government came to power in the state in May.

West Bengal minister Dilip Ghosh on Wednesday defended the killings of persons accused of crimes in alleged gunfights with the police, saying it was a “necessary act to decriminalise a criminalised society”, TV9 Bangla reported.

He said those who disapprove of the practice should “go to Bangladesh”, offering to facilitate their departure “without a visa”.

Since the terror attack in Jammu and Kashmir’s Pahalgam in April 2025, the police in several states ruled by the Bharatiya Janata Party have been detaining Bengali-speaking persons – mostly Muslims – and alleging that they are not Indian citizens.

Several persons have been forced into Bangladesh after they allegedly could not prove their Indian citizenship. In some cases, persons who were mistakenly sent to Bangladesh returned to the country after state authorities in India proved that they were Indians.

“There was a time when attempts were made to convert West Bengal into Bangladesh,” Ghosh said. “We will turn Bengal into Uttar Pradesh and Gujarat.”

Uttar Pradesh and Gujarat are BJP-ruled states.

Ghosh asserted that such killings would continue in the state and challenged “anyone who has the guts [to] try to stop us”.

“If required, many more things will happen,” he added. “Why talk only about encounters? Are bulldozers not being used? Society and politics have been criminalised. The law and the police are working to set things right.”

In Uttar Pradesh and some other states ruled by the BJP, demolitions targeting persons, often Muslims and other marginalised groups, who have been accused of crimes have become commonplace.

This is despite there being no provisions in Indian law that allow the authorities to demolish the property of persons accused of crimes as punishment.

In November 2024, the Supreme Court held that the practice was illegal and said that due process must be followed before the authorities remove allegedly illegal encroachments.

On Wednesday, Ghosh claimed that such killings and punitive actions take place across the world and in several states in India.

“Those who lack the strength to act do not resort to such measures,” he said. “Instead, they strike deals with criminals. Our government will not do that.”

He also made reference to women’s safety to defend the police action and warned that those harassing women, particularly Hindu women, would face consequences similar to those in the gunfight in Birbhum.

Recent alleged police gunfights

Ghosh’s remarks came following at least five deaths in alleged police gunfights across the state in the six months since the Bharatiya Janata Party came to power in May.

On Sunday, Ratan Sheikh, who was accused of shooting and injuring a constable two days earlier was killed in an alleged gunfight with the police in the Birbhum district.

On November 9, Dilip Roy, accused of raping and murdering a minor girl was killed in an alleged gunfight with the police in Raiganj.

On October 28, Prahlad Das, accused of raping and murdering a minor girl in North 24 Parganas, was shot dead in an alleged gunfight with the police.

On the same day, Samaul Sheikh, accused of murdering BJP worker Sujit Mondal in Murshidabad, was also killed in an alleged gunfight with the police.

On July 8, Prabhas Mondal, accused of raping and murdering a minor girl in South 24 Parganas, was shot dead by the police when he allegedly snatched an official’s rifle.

Edited by Nachiket Deuskar.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097176/go-to-bangladesh-bengal-minister-dismisses-criticism-of-killings-in-police-gunfights?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Thu, 19 Nov 2026 11:25:40 +0000 Scroll Staff
EC has limited powers against booth agents accused of filing false Form 7s to delete voters, says SC https://scroll.in/latest/1097187/ec-has-limited-powers-against-booth-agents-accused-of-filing-false-form-7s-to-delete-voters-says-sc?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The poll panel can blacklist the accused booth level agents but ‘beyond that, they have no control’, the bench noted.

The Supreme Court on Thursday said that the Election Commission has limited powers against booth level agents accused of filing fraudulent Form 7 applications to seek deletion of voters from electoral rolls, Bar and Bench reported.

Form 7 is used to object to the inclusion of a name or seek the deletion of an existing name from the electoral roll.

The court stated that the poll panel can blacklist the accused booth level agent, but “beyond that, they have no control”.

Booth-level agents are appointed by political parties for specific polling station areas to complement the Election Commission’s booth level officers during the preparation and revision of electoral rolls.

On Thursday, a bench headed by Chief Justice Surya Kant also directed the Election Commission and Delhi chief electoral officer to verify a complaint submitted by Congress leader Ali Mehdi alleging that false Form 7 applications were filed in northeastern Delhi’s Mustafabad Assembly constituency during the special intensive revision of electoral rolls, Live Law reported.

However, the bench declined to entertain Mehdi’s petition that alleged inaction by the Election Commissions on the complaints made in the regard.

“We dispose of this petition without expressing any opinion on the allegations, with a direction to the concerned authorities to verify the information submitted by the petitioner and take necessary remedial measures,” Bar and Bench quoted the court as saying.

In his petition, Mehdi had cited newspaper reports to allege that 28 electors against whom Form 7 applications had been filed were found living at their respective addresses during physical verification.

His counsel had submitted that following a representation to the Election Commission and the chief electoral officer of Delhi, the district election officer-cum-returning officer of East Delhi conducted a verification exercise and found that 37 such Form 7 applications had been filed by one booth-level agent.

On Thursday, Chief Justice Surya Kant said that the complaint should name the booth level agents concerned to enable an investigation.

On October 30, The Hindu reported that in polling part 129 of the Mustafabad constituency, voters listed in 28 Form 7s seeking their deletions were found to be living in the area.

The forms had been filled by a booth-level agent registered under the Bharatiya Janata Party, the newspaper had quoted the Election Commission’s records till October 28 as showing. The person had denied being an agent, filing the forms and being associated with the BJP, The Hindu reported at the time.

On November 6, the electoral registration officer of the constituency registered a police complaint seeking a first information report against the booth level agent.

Ajay Kumar, the district election officer in northeastern Delhi, had told The Hindu that officials of the poll panel had verified the newspaper’s October 30 report and found that 36 of the 37 Form 7s that had been filed by the agent to be false.

A complaint had been filed against the agent under the 1950 Representation of the People Act for making allegedly false declarations.

Delhi is among the 19 states and Union Territories where the voter roll revision is underway In the third phase.

A contentious exercise

Since the exercise began, concerns have been raised that the revision could eliminate genuine voters from the rolls and even shape electoral outcomes, as Scroll has reported.

The Supreme Court on October 30 asked the Election Commission in Uttar Pradesh to take “corrective steps” against Form 7 applications filed in bulk to delete voters’ names during the exercise.

On October 5, the Telangana chief electoral officer had directed officials to take action against persons misusing Form 7 to seek the deletion of eligible voters. This came four days after the Karnataka chief electoral officer said that legal action would be initiated against persons found to be filing bulk Form 7 applications.

In May, the Supreme Court upheld the legality of the revision. But it said that the exercise does not mean that the Election Commission can decide on whether the person is an Indian citizen.

Despite this, BJP-ruled states have cited the SIR to deny ration cards to those who have been eliminated from the rolls. In some cases, the police have denied permission for their passports to be renewed.

Since October 2, nationwide protests have been held calling for the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar over concerns about the functioning of the Election Commission and the alleged irregularities in how the voter roll is being revised.

Edited by Tanya Shrivastava.


Also read:


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097187/ec-has-limited-powers-against-booth-agents-accused-of-filing-false-form-7s-to-delete-voters-says-sc?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Thu, 19 Nov 2026 11:03:19 +0000 Scroll Staff
Madhya Pradesh scraps two-child norm for government jobs https://scroll.in/latest/1097181/madhya-pradesh-scraps-25-year-two-child-norm-for-government-jobs?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Employees who had already been removed from service under the rule will not have their cases reassessed after the rules are revoked.

Madhya Pradesh on Wednesday scrapped a 25-year-old rule that made persons with more than two children ineligible for state government jobs.

The rule was introduced in 2001 by the Congress government as a population control measure. It barred persons with more than two children from government jobs and provided for the dismissal of serving employees who had more than two children.

The Bharatiya Janata Party-led government has cited falling fertility rates in the state as the reason for repealing the policy, The Times of India reported.

However, employees who had already been dismissed from service under the rule will not have their cases reassessed after the rules are revoked, the newspaper reported.

Chhattisgarh had scrapped a similar restriction in its government recruitment policy in 2017.

Written by Abeer Khan. Edited by Tanya Shrivastava.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097181/madhya-pradesh-scraps-25-year-two-child-norm-for-government-jobs?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Thu, 19 Nov 2026 10:45:04 +0000 Scroll Staff
Supreme Court upholds interim bail to Azam Khan in ED case https://scroll.in/latest/1097184/supreme-court-upholds-interim-bail-to-azam-khan-in-ed-case?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The Allahabad HC on Tuesday granted bail to SP leader observing that Khan’s arrest by the Enforcement Directorate showed ‘motivated’ nature of the proceedings.

The Supreme Court on Thursday upheld the interim bail granted to Samajwadi Party leader Azam Khan in a money laundering case, Bar and Bench reported.

On Tuesday, Allahabad High Court granted bail to Khan observing that the circumstances of the case and the SP leader’s arrest by the Enforcement Directorate showed the “motivated and mala fide nature” of the proceedings.

On Thursday, the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal filed by the Enforcement Directorate against the High Court order.

It also noted that the High Court’s views in granting the bail would not influence the final decision in the matter.

Khan had approached the High Court, challenging his arrest in the case on October 31 outside the Rampur district jail, less than an hour after he was released from prison in another case.

The counsel for Khan had contended that the Enforcement Directorate had not provided him grounds for arrest, making his custody illegal.

Khan’s lawyer had also stated that the arrest was part of a political vendetta to keep the Samajwadi Party leader in jail till the Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections, which are expected to be held early next year.

The advocate representing the Enforcement Directorate had submitted before the High Court that Khan had been provided the grounds for arrest before the remand proceedings began. The lawyer was quoted as having claimed before the court that multiple officers had attempted to submit the documents to Khan, but he had repeatedly refused to accept them.

However, the bench observed that the arrest memo, the grounds for arrest and “reasons to believe the involvement” of Khan in the case “were not furnished” to him in writing “before or at any time before he was produced for remand”.

On Thursday, the Enforcement Directorate’s counsel reiterated that there is a video of Khan being given the grounds of arrest.

“Facts are wrongly recorded,” Bar and Bench quoted Additional Solicitor General SV Raju as saying.

The case

The current case against Khan relates to alleged financial irregularities involving the Mohammad Ali Jauhar University, which the former minister had founded.

Khan had served as the president of the Maulana Mohammad Ali Jauhar Trust, which operates the university. However, the Samajwadi Party leader and his family resigned from the trust in January.

The Enforcement Directorate has alleged that agricultural land belonging to farmers was forcibly occupied for the university.

It has further alleged that funds and materials meant for public works were diverted to the institution, government projects were executed on its private campus and money from contractors awarded government projects was routed back to the Mohammad Ali Jauhar Trust as donations.

The money laundering investigation in the matter was launched on the basis of around 26 first information reports registered by the Uttar Pradesh Police in 2019.

Edited by Tanya Shrivastava.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097184/supreme-court-upholds-interim-bail-to-azam-khan-in-ed-case?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Thu, 19 Nov 2026 09:04:34 +0000 Scroll Staff
Karnataka seeks SC nod to hold Bengaluru municipal polls using pre-SIR voter rolls https://scroll.in/latest/1097179/karnataka-seeks-sc-nod-to-hold-bengaluru-municipal-polls-using-pre-sir-voter-rolls?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The exercise led to a ‘staggering mass deletion’ of about 43 lakh names in the Greater Bengaluru Area, the Congress-led government said.

The Karnataka government and the State Election Commission have approached the Supreme Court seeking permission to conduct elections to the five municipal corporations in Bengaluru using voter lists that were published before the poll panel carried out the special intensive revision of the electoral rolls, The Indian Express reported on Thursday.

In its petition, the Congress-led state government said that the voter roll revision had drastically altered the city’s “electoral landscape” with the number of electors falling from about 1.03 crore to 59.08 lakh, the newspaper reported.

The exercise led to a “staggering mass deletion” of about 43 lakh names in the Greater Bengaluru Area, the government said in its plea.

As per the rolls published after the revision, the names of more than 99.3 lakh voters have been deleted in the state.

The number of voters fell to 4.5 crore from 5.5 crore that were on the electoral rolls before the exercise began. This amounts to a decrease of about 17.9%.

There were about 88.9 lakh voters in the five municipal corporations as per the electoral rolls published in April before the special intensive revision, according to the state poll panel.

The post-special intensive revision rolls had just over 59 lakh voters in the 28 Assembly constituencies in Bengaluru district, including rural areas. Excluding the rural areas, the figure stood at 51.8 lakh.

The state electoral panel also informed the Supreme Court that the Election Commission had not yet provided it with the authenticated database containing the revised electoral rolls, despite more than three weeks having passed since the final lists were published in October 27.

“Conducting the municipal elections without allowing the SEC the minimum required time of two months to process this drastically altered data would lead to an administrative chaos and widespread disenfranchisement on the polling day,” the government said.

In July as well, the state government had requested an extension to conduct the civic elections, citing the SIR. It had argued that conducting elections using unrevised electoral rolls before the revision process was completed could result in discrepancies, with voters appearing on one list but not the other.

On previous occasions, the government had also referred to constraints in human resources arising from Census-related duties and board examinations as reasons for seeking more time.

The tenure of the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike ended in September 2020. In January this year, the Supreme Court had set June 30 as the deadline for conducting the elections. This was subsequently extended to August 31 and then to December 31.

The Karnataka government has now sought a further extension, requesting that the deadline be moved to January 31.

Karnataka is among the 19 states and Union Territories where the voter roll revision was carried out in the third phase of SIR. The enumeration phase of the exercise in Karnataka began on June 30.

A contentious exercise

In 2025, the first phase of special intensive revision was conducted in Bihar. It was extended to 12 states and Union Territories in the second phase in late 2025 and the first half of 2026.

Since the exercise began, concerns have been raised that the revision could eliminate genuine voters from the rolls and even shape electoral outcomes, as Scroll has reported.

In May, the Supreme Court upheld the legality of the revision. But it said that the exercise does not mean that the Election Commission can decide on whether the person is an Indian citizen.

Despite this, Bharatiya Janata Party-ruled states have cited the SIR to deny ration cards to those who have been eliminated from the rolls. In some cases, the police have denied permission for their passports to be renewed.

Edited by Nachiket Deuskar.


Also read:


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097179/karnataka-seeks-sc-nod-to-hold-bengaluru-municipal-polls-using-pre-sir-voter-rolls?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Thu, 19 Nov 2026 08:11:43 +0000 Scroll Staff
Hire locals, will not tolerate attempts to recruit outsiders: Omar Abdullah tells firms in J&K https://scroll.in/latest/1097178/hire-locals-will-not-tolerate-attempts-to-recruit-outsiders-omar-abdullah-tells-firms-in-j-k?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The government will not accept ‘the excuse that trained local youngsters are not available’, the chief minister said.

Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Omar Abdullah has said that companies setting up operations in the Union Territory would have to employ local youth, The Indian Express reported on Thursday.

He added that his government “will not tolerate attempts to recruit people from outside”.

His remarks came against the backdrop of demands for the restoration of Jammu and Kashmir’s statehood and special status. The National Conference government has faced criticism from the Opposition for failing to secure these demands.

The restoration of statehood and special status were among the key promises in the National Conference’s 2024 Assembly election manifesto.

On Tuesday, during an event, Abdullah said that companies could be given six months to a year to train local youth if they did not find suitably trained candidates in the region, The Indian Express reported.

He added: “We will not tolerate the excuse that trained local youngsters are not available.”

In August 2019, the Union government abrogated Article 370 of the Constitution, which granted special status to Jammu and Kashmir, and bifurcated the erstwhile state into two Union Territories: Jammu and Kashmir, and Ladakh.

New rules were introduced in 2020 that allow outsiders who have lived in Jammu and Kashmir for 15 years or studied there for seven years to apply for a domicile certificate. The certificates allow individuals to apply for government jobs and buy property in the Union Territory.

Under Article 370, only permanent residents of Jammu and Kashmir could apply for government jobs and own land there. The provision had also barred non-state subjects from residing in the region permanently.

In December 2023, the Supreme Court upheld the validity of the 2019 order abrogating Article 370 and ordered the Union government to restore statehood to Jammu and Kashmir.

In October 2025, Union Home Minister Amit Shah said that statehood would be restored to Jammu and Kashmir at an “appropriate time” after discussions with political stakeholders.

Edited by Nachiket Deuskar.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097178/hire-locals-will-not-tolerate-attempts-to-recruit-outsiders-omar-abdullah-tells-firms-in-j-k?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Thu, 19 Nov 2026 07:27:33 +0000 Scroll Staff
India will not sign trade deal till new US tariff framework takes shape: Commerce secretary https://scroll.in/latest/1097175/india-will-not-sign-trade-deal-till-new-us-tariff-framework-takes-shape-commerce-secretary?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Rajesh Agrawal, the bureaucrat, said that all aspects of the agreement had more or less been finalised.

India and the United States are close to finalising negotiations for a bilateral trade agreement, but the deal will not be signed until Washington sets up a new tariffs framework, the Deccan Herald quoted Commerce Secretary Rajesh Agrawal as saying on Wednesday.

After an interim trade deal was agreed upon on February 2, US tariffs on Indian goods would have been reduced to 18% from a combined rate of 50%. The earlier rate of 50% had included a punitive levy of 25% imposed in August 2025 over India’s purchase of Russian oil.

However, negotiations on the final deal were hampered after the US Supreme Court on February 20 struck down global tariffs imposed by President Donald Trump, ruling that he had exceeded his authority.

In response, Trump imposed a temporary 10% tariff on goods imported into the US, citing his authority under the 1974 Trade Act. This had left the status of US’ trade deals with all countries, including India, unclear.

The commerce secretary was quoted as saying that all aspects of the deal were “more or less finalised” and an interim agreement was imminent.

However, Agrawal said that the deal could only be signed after the US’ new tariff framework comes into effect and investigations under Section 301 are concluded, Moneycontrol reported. The provision allows the US to investigate and impose tariffs or trade sanctions against countries over unfair trade practices.

“You can’t have a deal till you have got uncertainty around multiple investigations or which are already there,” the commerce secretary was quoted as saying. “So, I think those numbers and the actual deal will be signed and operationalised once these investigations are over and they are [reaching maturity].”

Agrawal made the comments at an event organised by the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry.

Agrawal also said that the government was trying to conclude negotiations on some other trade deals by the end of the year with some “good news” expected in December, The Times of India reported, adding that it was seen as a reference to ongoing talks with Canada.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi is expected to visit Canada in December.

Edited by Nachiket Deuskar.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097175/india-will-not-sign-trade-deal-till-new-us-tariff-framework-takes-shape-commerce-secretary?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Thu, 19 Nov 2026 04:21:00 +0000 Scroll Staff
Why a ropeway project has set off alarm bells in Shillong https://scroll.in/article/1097163/why-a-ropeway-project-has-set-off-alarm-bells-in-shillong?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Protestors say it endangers their water security and Lum Shyllong, a forested hill from which the city gets its name.

For 12 days now, elderly women have been camping day and night near the Meghalaya state secretariat in Shillong to demand the scrapping of a ropeway project in the city.

In December 2024, the state government announced ropeway of nearly a kilometre that would allow tourists to ride cable cars to the Shillong Peak, a famous tourist spot. The Meghalaya government has claimed the project would generate at least Rs 10 crore in revenue every year, creating jobs and business for local residents.

However, the Joint Action Committee Against the Shillong Ropeway Project, a platform formed by the residents of the Laban Pyllun area, however, say that the project will endanger streams and water sources in Lum Shyllong, a sacred forested hill from which Shillong gets its name.

“All the drinking water that is supplied to the whole city of Shillong comes from that Lum Shyllong area,” Deborah Marbaniang, who heads the joint action committee, told Scroll.

The government has denied that the Rs 175 crore project would put water sources at risk. Deputy Chief Minister Prestone Tynsong said that the state government will not scrap or relocate the project on the basis of “unfounded fears”.

‘A forest that sustains’

According to Khasi mythology, Lum Shyllong, the site of the ropeway project, is home to Lei Shyllong, the deity of nine river sources in the area.

“These nine river sources give rise to other tributaries along their course, nourishing paddy and agricultural fields,” Kyrsoibor Pyrtuh, a Shillong-based pastor, wrote in an article.

Poet and writer Janice Pariat, who collected government records from 1883 to 1910, documenting the city's water-supply arrangements, described the city’s dependence on streams and springs originating in the Shillong range.

“The British, when they build the city in the early 1860s, constantly worried about how to secure the water supply for Shillong,” Pariat told Scroll. “So they planted all of the slopes around the town with forests, with pines to create natural catchment areas. It wasn’t just an aesthetic, it was a hydraulic necessity,” she said.

Cutting “into a catchment forest can disturb an ecosystem that sustains our town”, Pariat said in an Instagram post.

“The felling of over 544 mature trees for the project is already affecting the water supply,” said Marbaniang, of the Joint Action Committee. At least 2,000 more trees are expected to be cut for the project.

Pariat feared that the number may be more. “Who knows how many trees are there in the 2.3 hectares that have been cleared?” she asked.

She argued that the ropeway project will involve considerable disruption to the hill.

“It's not one house or two houses being built,” she said. “It is a stretch of ropeway that involves landing platforms, posts that will carry the cable cars along the way.”

In a sensitive seismic zone, building posts as high as 40 metres high, Pariat said, “is very worrying”.

The project

The ropeway aims to bring more visitors to the Shillong Peak, where tourists often gather for a bird’s-eye view of the sprawling hill station, perched 1,966 m above sea level.

According to the Meghalaya Ropeway Development Authority, the project secured “all mandatory approvals” before work began last October.

This includes “clearance from the Union Ministry of Environment” for diversion of 2.32 hectares of forest land. The government has said that land for the project has been leased by the Riat Laban Dorbar Pyllun.

The Dorbar Shnong is the highest traditional administrative body in a Khasi village.

The government also said that a public consultation for the project was held in September 2022, with representatives of the Dorbar present.

However, the Joint Action Committeehas called it a sham. “It is a lie that there was a public hearing,” Marbaniang told The Shillong Times.

CVD Diengdoh, the CEO of the Meghalaya Ropeway Development Authority, has asserted that the project “will not affect” any water source and its impact on the catchment area will be “negligible” .

“The six towers [to be built in the project] would occupy only 0.2 per cent of the total catchment area. Spring sources 500 metres to one kilometre further away would remain unaffected,” he told the reporters after meeting with members of the Joint Action Committee. The project is designed to pass above the tree line to minimise felling, he said.

In another meeting, the government asserted that the project would not affect the Umiew catchment that is a source for the Greater Shillong Water Supply Scheme. The assurance did not convince the Joint Action Committee, which walked out of the meeting.

Opposition from the district council

The project has also put the National People's Party-led government at loggerheads with the Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council or KHADC.

The council is currently run by the Khasi nationalist Opposition party, Voice of People’s Party.

Under the Sixth Schedule of the Constitution, Meghalaya has three autonomous district councils with legislative, executive and financial powers. The councils also strictly regulate the grant of trading licences to non-tribal players.

The KHADC has alleged that the company carrying out the project, KEC International Ltd and Tantia Construction Ltd, has failed to obtain a mandatory trading licence from the council.

On October 27, the council objected to the movement of heavy machinery to the construction site before the necessary permissions were secured and locked the gates of the lower terminal site of the proposed ropeway project at Lawsohtun.

Two days later, the government lodged a first information report against an inspector of the Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council for sealing the lower terminal site.

“We locked the gates as the company is yet to obtain the mandatory trading licence from the council,” Denzil R Chen, executive member of the council, told Scroll. “This is a private company, a non-tribal entity. For any kind of commercial activity within the council's jurisdiction, they have to take a clearance from us.”

A divide

While the opposition to the ropeway grows, experts point out the lack of a rigorous environmental audit of the project.

Professor Devesh Walia, who teaches geology at the North-Eastern Hill University Act, said the ropeway, if it runs above the tree line, is not expected to create a lot of damage.

He called for “more scientific evidence” rather than only “emotional appeals” so that the government can be convinced.

To objections that springs in the area have already dried out, Walia said that could be an impact of variable rainfall.

“Earlier, there used to be very long spells of rainfall, allowing for more water to seep into the ground and recharge groundwater,” he said. “That has changed. But we cannot say outright that the project will lead to springs drying up – without evidence.”

Walia said a scientific study should be carried out to determine the impact. He also said if the government has undertaken such a study, they should disclose its findings.

A minister in the government proposed an independent expert panel, with representatives of the Indian Institutes of Technology, to examine the project. The Joint Action Committee has rejected the suggestion, saying nothing short of scrapping the project would be acceptable.

A Shillong-based political activist said residents of the Laban area, where the ropeway has been proposed, are divided. Half of them support the project, he claimed.

“It has just been made into a huge issue by people with no technical expertise,” he said. “Where is the study which says it will impact water sources? The government has asserted they will not be touched.”

He said the objections of the Joint Action Committee have brought the government to the negotiating table and they can continue to supervise the project so that no water sources are damaged. “But it is not about the environment,” he said. “Your ultimate objective is to stop the ropeway because it is in your backyard and you do not want tourism to come to Laban.”

However, Marbaniang pointed out that the ropeway project risks the green cover of the entire city and not just the Laban area. It would be a blow for the 15-km stretch of green cover of the hill.

“We no longer have such forests in Shillong,” Marbaniang said. “We have to protect them for the future generation. We will agitate till the government scraps this project.”

]]>
https://scroll.in/article/1097163/why-a-ropeway-project-has-set-off-alarm-bells-in-shillong?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Thu, 19 Nov 2026 01:00:03 +0000 Rokibuz Zaman
No non-veg food during ‘Ramayana: Part 1’ screenings, says Bengal multiplex https://scroll.in/latest/1097165/no-non-veg-food-during-ramayana-part-1-screenings-says-bengal-multiplex?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt ‘Some films are more than cinema,’ stated Kolkata-based SVF Cinemas.

A Kolkata-based multiplex chain has said that it will not serve non-vegetarian food inside theatres during screenings of Ramayana: Part 1, so that the viewers “can enjoy the film and their devotion to the fullest”, The Indian Express reported on Tuesday.

SVF Cinemas stated that the restriction would apply only during the screening of the film, which is an adaptation of the Hindu epic Ramayana.

“Some films are more than cinema,” The Indian Express quoted an unidentified spokesperson of the chain as saying. “When the [Hindu hymn] Hanuman Chalisa plays during Ramayana, the auditorium almost feels like a temple, and we feel it too.”

The company added that viewers had previously asked it to serve only vegetarian food inside theatres during screenings of other movies based on Hindu mythology.

“As a small, heartfelt gesture, we will serve only vegetarian food inside the auditorium during screenings of Ramayana,” it said.

Released on November 5, Ramayana: Part 1 is directed by Nitesh Tiwari and features Ranbir Kapoor, Yash and Sai Pallavi in lead roles.

Edited by Sneha.


Also read: ‘Ramayana: Part 1’ review: A sleek and sumptuous spectacle


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097165/no-non-veg-food-during-ramayana-part-1-screenings-says-bengal-multiplex?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Wed, 18 Nov 2026 14:58:42 +0000 Scroll Staff
MP: Six police officers suspended for threatening to plant marijuana on couple https://scroll.in/latest/1097164/mp-six-police-officers-suspended-for-threatening-to-plant-marijuana-on-couple?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt A video of the incident widely shared on social media shows an officer identified as Seoni Additional Superintendent of Police Deepak Mishra making the threats.

Six Madhya Pradesh Police officers, including an additional superintendent of police, were suspended on Wednesday after a video purportedly showed them threatening to plant marijuana on two persons in Seoni district, Chief Minister Mohan Yadav said.

The video, shared widely on social media, showed a police officer, identified as Additional Superintendent of Police Deepak Mishra, speaking to an unmarried man and woman who were staying at a private hotel. The officer can be heard threatening to call their parents. When the woman asks him not to do so, he says: “We will not call your parents, but then we will keep ganja in your bag.”

The suspended personnel are Mishra, Seoni Sub Divisional Police Officer Chanchlesh Markam, Kotwali police station in-charge Inspector Satish Tiwari, Head Constable Naveen Tiwari, and Mishra’s driver and gunman, Salman Khan and Krishna Tiwari, The Hindu reported.

An investigation has been launched into the matter, Yadav said.

“Every officer and employee responsible for maintaining law and order in the state is expected to discharge their duties with responsibility, propriety and discipline,” the chief minister added. “Under the zero-tolerance policy toward misconduct, strict action will be ensured against those found guilty.”

A departmental inquiry has also been initiated on the orders of Jabalpur Zone Inspector General of Police Promod Verma, The Hindu reported.

Written by Tanya Shrivastava. Edited by Sneha.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097164/mp-six-police-officers-suspended-for-threatening-to-plant-marijuana-on-couple?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Wed, 18 Nov 2026 14:03:46 +0000 Scroll Staff
Rush Hour: Sexual assault cases against Delhi Police officers closed, HC relief for Kochhar & more https://scroll.in/latest/1097162/rush-hour-sexual-assault-cases-against-delhi-police-officers-closed-hc-relief-for-kochhar-more?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Become a Scroll member to get Rush Hour – a wrap of the day’s important stories delivered straight to your inbox every evening.

Could your home be at risk from rising seas? Scroll is investigating coastal flooding in Mumbai and Kolkata, mapping vulnerable areas and examining whether developers and the authorities are accounting for the risks. Support this investigation and help us make this reporting possible. Fund the project here.


Allegations by three women journalists that police officers sexually assaulted them while they were reporting on protests against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar in October could not be corroborated, the Delhi Police has told the Supreme Court. The police said that the three complaints had been closed.

The police also said that there was no strict rule requiring only women police personnel to handle women during crowd-control operations.

It further said that the Supreme Court’s October direction to the police not to “hinder” journalists in the discharge of their duties did not extend to “so-called reel-makers and social media influencers”. Read on.

‘Groped and pushed’: Women allege sexual harassment while being detained during Delhi protests, report Nolina Minj and Vaishnavi Rathore


The Bombay High Court set aside the sanction that ICICI Bank’s board granted the Central Bureau of Investigation to prosecute Chanda Kochhar, its former managing director and chief executive officer. The case pertains to the alleged irregularities in the about Rs 3,250 crore loan ICICI Bank granted to the Videocon Group in 2012.

The CBI had alleged that ICICI Bank, under the leadership of Kochhar, granted loans to Videocon in contravention of the rules and policy of the sanctioning committee.

The court said that the sanction granted in May 2023 was illegal and “deserves to be set aside” on the grounds that the board did not have the power to do so. Read on.


The Supreme Court sought responses from the Congress, the Aam Aadmi Party, the Cockroach Janta Party political campaign and the All India Students Association on a petition by traders associations alleging that protests against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar in October led to losses to their businesses in New Delhi. The bench also sought responses from the Union and Delhi governments.

In their petition, the traders’ associations also objected to the designation of Ramlila Ground as a protest venue. They said that Ramlila Maidan was “surrounded by dense residential localities and wholesale and retail markets of Old Delhi, where thousands of workers, traders and vendors operate”.

They argued that the designation was made without a published assessment of its impact on residents and businesses. Read on.


Lateef Bhat, a commander of the Lashkar-e-Taiba terror group, was killed in a gunfight in Kulgam, said the Jammu and Kashmir Police. Bhat carried a bounty of Rs 15 lakh and was wanted for his alleged involvement in an attack on the Central Reserve Police Force on November 11, in which three security personnel were killed.

The militant was also allegedly involved in the attacks in Anantnag and Kulgam districts in July. Read on.


If you haven’t already, sign up for our Daily Brief newsletter.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097162/rush-hour-sexual-assault-cases-against-delhi-police-officers-closed-hc-relief-for-kochhar-more?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Wed, 18 Nov 2026 13:17:57 +0000 Scroll Staff
BSF constable who ‘inadvertently’ crossed Bangladesh border returned after flag meeting https://scroll.in/latest/1097149/bsf-personnel-who-inadvertently-crossed-bangladesh-border-returned-after-flag-meeting?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The constable reportedly crossed from Meghalaya’s Jowai into Bangladesh’s Sylhet district, venturing around 200 yards across the international border.

A Border Security Force constable was detained on Tuesday by Bangladesh’s border guarding force after he “inadvertently” crossed the unfenced international border around noon, The Indian Express reported.

The constable returned safely in the evening after a meeting between commanders from both sides, the newspaper added.

The BSF constable reportedly crossed the international border from Meghalaya’s Jowai into Bangladesh’s Sylhet district, venturing around 180 metres across the border, India Today NE reported.

He was carrying a walkie-talkie, an Indian Small Arms System rifle and a pump-action gun at the time of his detention, The Shillong Times reported.

Videos shared on social media showed two Border Guard Bangladesh officers and several residents accompanying the Indian constable after he crossed the border. In one of the videos, he was seen being taken away by Bangladeshi personnel on a civilian motorcycle, The Indian Express reported.

After the Border Security Force took cognisance of the videos, senior officers deployed in Meghalaya contacted their Bangladeshi counterparts and called for a flag meeting, The Shillong Times reported.

The Border Security Force guards a 4,096-km-long stretch of border between India and Bangladesh.

Edited by Sara Varghese.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097149/bsf-personnel-who-inadvertently-crossed-bangladesh-border-returned-after-flag-meeting?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Wed, 18 Nov 2026 13:02:39 +0000 Scroll Staff
CEC protests: SC seeks Congress, AAP, CJP response on traders’ plea alleging business losses https://scroll.in/latest/1097161/cec-protests-sc-seeks-congress-aap-cjp-response-on-traders-plea-alleging-business-losses?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The petition has also challenged the designation of Ramlila Maidan as a venue for demonstration.

The Supreme Court on Wednesday sought responses from the Congress, the Aam Aadmi Party, the Cockroach Janta Party political campaign and the All India Students Association on a petition by traders’ associations alleging that protests against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar in October led to losses to their businesses in New Delhi, Live Law reported.

A bench headed by Chief Justice Surya Kant also sought responses from the Union and Delhi governments, the Hindustan Times reported.

The protests, which began on October 2 and continued through most of the month, were held in Connaught Place and at Ramlila Ground in Central Delhi. They called for Kumar’s resignation over alleged irregularities in the conduct of the special intensive revision of electoral rolls and concerns about the functioning of the Election Commission.

In their petition, the traders’ associations also objected to the designation of Ramlila Ground as a protest venue. On October 12, the Delhi Police denotified Jantar Mantar as a designated protest site in the national capital. Ramlila Ground was one of the sites proposed as an alternative to Jantar Mantar for demonstrations.

The traders said that Ramlila Maidan was “surrounded by dense residential localities and wholesale and retail markets of Old Delhi, where thousands of workers, traders and vendors operate”, the Hindustan Times reported.

They argued that the designation was made without a published assessment of its impact on residents and businesses, or safeguards concerning the number of demonstrators, duration of protests, damage to property and liability.

The case is expected to be heard next on November 27.

Edited by Tanya Shrivastava.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097161/cec-protests-sc-seeks-congress-aap-cjp-response-on-traders-plea-alleging-business-losses?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Wed, 18 Nov 2026 12:36:12 +0000 Scroll Staff
EC extends SIR timelines in six states https://scroll.in/latest/1097156/ec-extends-sir-timelines-in-six-states?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The final voter rolls in Andhra Pradesh, Haryana, Jharkhand, Maharashtra, Nagaland and Telangana will now be published on December 22 instead of November 30.

The Election Commission has extended the timeline for the special intensive revision of electoral rolls in Andhra Pradesh, Haryana, Jharkhand, Maharashtra, Nagaland and Telangana, revising the schedule for the distribution and collection of enumeration forms and the disposal of claims and objections, IANS reported.

The final electoral rolls in the six states will now be published on December 22, instead of November 30, the newspaper reported.

As per the revised schedule, enumeration forms for voters will be distributed and collected between Wednesday and November 30.

The process of dealing with the forms received, including those relating to voters categorised as absent, shifted, dead and duplicate, will have to be completed by December 10.

The states are among the 19 states and Union Territories where the voter roll revision is being carried out in the third phase of SIR.

A contentious exercise

In 2025, the first phase of special intensive revision was conducted in Bihar. It was extended to 12 states and Union Territories in the second phase in late 2025 and the first half of 2026.

Since the exercise began, concerns have been raised that the revision could eliminate genuine voters from the rolls and even shape electoral outcomes, as Scroll has reported.

In May, the Supreme Court upheld the legality of the revision. But it said that the exercise does not mean that the Election Commission can decide on whether the person is an Indian citizen.

Despite this, Bharatiya Janata Party-ruled states have cited the SIR to deny ration cards to those who have been eliminated from the rolls. In some cases, the police have denied permission for their passports to be renewed.

Edited by Tanya Shrivastava.


Also read:


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097156/ec-extends-sir-timelines-in-six-states?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Wed, 18 Nov 2026 11:17:56 +0000 Scroll Staff
HC sets aside ICICI Bank’s sanction to prosecute ex-chief Chanda Kochhar in Videocon loan case https://scroll.in/latest/1097159/hc-sets-aside-icici-banks-sanction-to-prosecute-ex-chief-chanda-kochhar-in-videocon-loan-case?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The case pertains to the alleged irregularities in the about Rs 3,250 crore loan granted to the Videocon Group in 2012.

The Bombay High Court on Wednesday set aside the sanction ICICI Bank’s board granted the Central Bureau of Investigation to prosecute Chanda Kochhar, its former managing director and chief executive officer, in the Videocon loan case, Bar and Bench reported.

The case pertains to the alleged irregularities in the about Rs 3,250 crore loan ICICI Bank, under Chanda Kochhar’s leadership, granted to the Videocon Group in 2012.

The CBI had begun investigating the matter in January 2018 after reports that Videocon promoter VN Dhoot allegedly paid a firm he had allegedly set up with Chanda Kochhar’s husband, Deepak Kochhar, among others, six months after his firm got the loan from ICICI Bank, Live Law reported.

The investigating agency alleged that ICICI Bank had granted loans to Videocon in contravention of the rules and policy of the sanctioning committee.

Chanda Kochhar had moved the court challenging the sanction to prosecute her, arguing that the bank did not follow the proper procedure.

On Wednesday, the bench accepted her argument and said that the sanction granted in May 2023 was illegal and “deserves to be set aside” on the grounds that the board did not have the power to do so.

The board “completely failed to apply its mind to the material, or lack thereof, placed before it while granting sanction, thereby warranting interference of this court”, the judge was quoted as having observed.

Chanda Kochhar’s counsel had also contended that the sanction granted by ICICI Bank under the Prevention of Corruption Act contradicted its earlier position that the bank had not suffered any loss as a result of the loans being allowed and that they were in line with its policies, Live Law reported.

She resigned from the bank in October 2018 after questions arose about loans to the Videocon Group.

In December 2022, the CBI arrested the Kochhars in the case. A month later, the Bombay High Court ordered their release, saying that their arrests were not in accordance with the law.

In February 2024, the High Court said that their arrest amounted to an abuse of power.

Edited by Sneha.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097159/hc-sets-aside-icici-banks-sanction-to-prosecute-ex-chief-chanda-kochhar-in-videocon-loan-case?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Wed, 18 Nov 2026 10:46:25 +0000 Scroll Staff
Readers’ comments: On Tagore, can Bangladesh accept ‘Hindu’ poet who spoke of universal values? https://scroll.in/article/1097116/readers-comments-on-tagore-can-bangladesh-accept-hindu-poet-who-spoke-of-universal-values?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Responses to articles in Scroll.in.

I am not sure how the decision was made to include Elli Benaiah’s article on the cuisine of the so-called Jewish community in Andhra Pradesh (“The kitchen came first, then god: Five recipes from an emerging Jewish community in Andhra Pradesh”). Devoid of any literary or culinary value, it seems to be a thinly-veiled attempt at seeding Jewish ancestry wherever the author fancies.

The author then says “it really is not a comfortable thing to be a Jew at present”. Did Scroll let this article pass without editing? Are the publication and the author in ignorance of Israel’s apartheid in Palestine and the three years of genocide? Publish or not this letter, but my ability to read Scroll with trust is broken. – Venkatesh

Bangladesh and Tagore

The author has given many suggestions about how Rabindranath Tagore should be estimated, judged and interpreted by present-day Bangladeshis (“In Bangladesh, Rabindranath Tagore has become a fractured inheritance”). But anyone estimates, judges and interprets an artist at their consciousness and wisdom. In this world, it is unlikely to find someone who is unanimously accepted and respected.

But finally, Tagore’s appeal lies in the universality of his art and work. It is not modernity that will determine the acceptance and fate of Tagore in Bangladesh, but how long Muslim-majority Bangladesh will tolerate the cultural and spiritual dominance of a Hindu Rabindranath. The tragedy is that Tagore never considered himself a Hindu or a Muslim, but a human being who found human unity amid diversity. – Amitbaran Dewanji

***

Tagore has been given far more privilege over other Bengali poets. Tagore was against the establishment of Dhaka University the Partition of Bengal. There is no need to be blind in worshipping him. – Mdn

Blind votebank

Just like the votebank of secular and Left parties were upper caste and lower caste Muslims, being the true votebank means the party you claim as your protector ensures that your rights and socio-economic prosperity are never realised (“Does Modi want to prevent middle-class Indians from investing abroad?”). The same thing is happening to the middle-class Hindu vote bank of the Bharatiya Janata Party. These votebanks are trapped with identity and ideology and kill their own leverage.

These parties keep them distracted with divisive politics and are not interested in governance, reforms or improving material prosperity. Hindus nor Muslims will ever prosper unless they confront this. Just like the Congress and the Communists took Dalits and Muslims for granted and paid for it by losing legitimacy, the BJP will follow the same path after losing the trust of its middle-class support base. – Ved Chavan

India’s election chief

I am now 78. Having not been aware of this profound testament to the conduct of elections, I always held a conviction that independent India had two outstanding stalwarts – Justice Jagmohanlal Sinha (who set aside Indira Gandhi's election) and TN Seshan (“Flashback: When CEC Lyngdoh refused BJP demand for early Gujarat poll until voter roll was updated”). Lyngdoh should also be placed and honoured along with the two in the hall of fame of our independent India. I salute this trinity and offer my sincere pranaam to them. – Hemmanur Ravindra

SIR exercise

If only banks too did the same (“Karnataka chief electoral office admits multiple voter IDs generated for same person during SIR”) ! So many Karnataka folks have multiple bank accounts too. But of course they would not like their own account number being issued to another client. – Sundar BN

***

So much for centralised election software. The Supreme Court needs to put a stop to this god forsaken nonsense. – S Mellachervu

***

The conduct of the Supreme Court is, at the very least, shameful and totally unacceptable. It’s an unimaginable lapse on the part of a Supreme Court judge to be casual about millions of eligible voters being deprived of their rights and to only say vote “next time”. There should be a mass movement to throw out not only the Chief Election Commissioner but also errant judges. – S Afzal

Repairing technology

This was a well thought-out episode of EcoIndia (“Eco India: Why India needs to revive its repair culture to curb e-waste”). It avoided a superficial analysis of “jugaad culture”. When you look at a phone or laptop from just five years ago, one sees that the design philosophy has changed completely 180 degrees. Forcing companies to make phones in a particular way might kill innovation or prove difficult to enforce with technicalities.

The easiest way is to force companies to sell original spare parts in an open market – like for car service – it creates an economy around it where anyone can buy parts, repair their devices themselves or hire a local technician. This will eliminate the hidden incentive of company service centres and the few big repair centres.

It should start with batteries which are the most critical part of a smartphone. That can be enforced with a battery buyback mandate. There can also be other incentives, like tax cuts to rebates on phones using modular design like the Fairphones. – Aseem

]]>
https://scroll.in/article/1097116/readers-comments-on-tagore-can-bangladesh-accept-hindu-poet-who-spoke-of-universal-values?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Wed, 18 Nov 2026 10:00:00 +0000 Scroll
Karnataka HC stays police probe in 3 more cases over ‘fraudulent’ Form 7 use to delete Muslim voters https://scroll.in/latest/1097154/karnataka-hc-stays-police-probe-in-3-more-cases-over-fraudulent-form-7-use-to-delete-muslim-voters?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt In October, the court had two similar investigations on hold.

The Karnataka High Court on Tuesday stayed investigations in three cases against 10 persons accused of fraudulently using Form 7s of the Election Commission to delete Muslim voters during the special intensive revision of electoral rolls in the state, Bar and Bench reported.

Form 7 is used to object to the inclusion of a name or seek the deletion of an existing name from the electoral roll.

In October, the court stayed probes in two other similar cases.

On Tuesday, the court directed the poll panel to place on record materials relating to decisions taken on the use of Form 7. The bench observed that the statutory inquiry into their correctness under the 1960 Registration of Electors Rules should first be completed, Bar and Bench reported.

The FIRs had been filed after complainants alleged that Form 7s had been submitted in bulk based on false information, forged signatures and impersonation to remove eligible electors, mainly Muslims, from voter lists.

The Congress-led state government had opposed the petitions seeking a stay. It contended that the right to vote was extremely valuable and that fake or forged forms cannot be allowed, Bar and Bench reported.

The petitioners had argued that booth-level agents were entitled to file Form 7s on behalf of political parties and that the correctness of the applications had to be examined by the electoral registration officer.

Political parties appoint booth-level agents for specific polling station areas to complement the Election Commission’s booth level officers during the preparation and revision of electoral rolls.

The court examined rules in the 1960 Registration of Electors Rules pertaining to the scrutiny of claims and objections, inquiries and hearings, Bar and Bench reported.

The bench noted that the rules also provide for imprisonment of up to one year, a fine, or both, for making a knowingly false written declaration.

The court said that if the electoral registration officer had to complete the inquiry before deciding whether further police investigation into the alleged offences was warranted, the legal news outlet reported.

A contentious exercise

In 2025, the first phase of the voter roll revision was conducted in Bihar. It was extended to 12 states and Union Territories in the second phase in late 2025 and the first half of 2026. The third phase of the exercise, in 19 states and Union Territories, is underway.

Since the exercise began, concerns have been raised that the revision could eliminate genuine voters from the rolls and even shape electoral outcomes, as Scroll has reported.

In May, the Supreme Court upheld the legality of the revision. But it said that the exercise does not mean that the Election Commission can decide on whether the person is an Indian citizen.

Despite this, Bharatiya Janata Party-ruled states have cited the SIR to deny ration cards to those who have been eliminated from the rolls. In some cases, the police have denied permission for their passports to be renewed.

Since October 2, nationwide protests have been held calling for the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar over concerns about the functioning of the Election Commission and the alleged irregularities in how the voter roll is being revised.

Edited by Tanya Shrivastava.


Also read: Follow Scroll’s coverage of the special intensive revision of electoral rolls here.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097154/karnataka-hc-stays-police-probe-in-3-more-cases-over-fraudulent-form-7-use-to-delete-muslim-voters?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Wed, 18 Nov 2026 09:35:27 +0000 Scroll Staff
Azam Khan granted bail in ED case, Allahabad HC says arrest ‘motivated’ https://scroll.in/latest/1097147/azam-khan-granted-bail-in-ed-case-allahabad-hc-says-arrest-motivated?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The court observed that the Enforcement Directorate had not followed the lawful procedure while taking the Samajwadi Party leader into custody.

The Allahabad High Court on Tuesday granted interim bail to former Uttar Pradesh minister Azam Khan in a money laundering case filed against him by the Enforcement Directorate, Live Law reported.

The court observed that the circumstances of the case and Khan’s arrest showed the “motivated and mala fide nature” of the proceedings.

The observations came on a plea filed by Khan challenging his arrest in the case. He had been arrested on October 31 outside the Rampur district jail, less than an hour after he was released from prison in another case.

The counsel for Khan had contended that the Enforcement Directorate had not provided him grounds for arrest, making his custody illegal, Bar and Bench reported.

Khan’s lawyer also contended that the arrest was part of a political vendetta to keep the Samajwadi Party leader in jail till the Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections, which are expected to be held early next year, Live Law reported.

The advocate representing the Enforcement Directorate contended that Khan had been provided the grounds for arrest before the remand proceedings began. The lawyer was quoted as having claimed before the court that multiple officers had attempted to submit the documents to Khan, but he had repeatedly refused to accept them.

However, the bench observed that the arrest memo, the grounds for arrest and “reasons to believe the involvement” of Khan in the case “were not furnished” to him in writing “before or at any time before he was produced for remand”, Live Law reported.

The court said that the Enforcement Directorate had verbally informed Khan about the grounds for arrest after the former minister refused to receive the documents.

The bench also noted that the Enforcement Directorate had not submitted any video or photograph showing officers asking Khan to accept the documents stating the grounds for arrest and the leader refusing them, Live Law reported.

The bench said that it appeared that the Enforcement Directorate had not followed the procedure guaranteed to Khan under Article 22(1) of the Constitution and Section 19 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act. Article 22(1) pertains to the right to be informed about the grounds for arrest and Section 19 of the Act deals with the power to arrest.

The relief for Khan will remain in force until court hears the matter further on December 10.

ED challenges bail

On Wednesday, the Enforcement Directorate approached the Supreme Court challenging the High Court’s interim bail granted to Khan, PTI reported.

The agency sought urgent hearing on the plea and urged that status quo be maintained while the matter was being heard.

However, the bench said that “heavens are not going to fall” if Khan is on an interim bail, and said that the plea will be listed for hearing on Thursday, the news agency reported.

The case

The current case against Khan relates to alleged financial irregularities involving the Mohammad Ali Jauhar University, which the former minister had founded, Bar and Bench reported.

Khan had served as the president of the Maulana Mohammad Ali Jauhar Trust, which operates the university. However, the Samajwadi Party leader and his family resigned from the trust in January.

The Enforcement Directorate has alleged that agricultural land belonging to farmers was forcibly occupied for the university.

It has further alleged that funds and materials meant for public works were diverted to the institution, government projects were executed on its private campus and money from contractors awarded government projects was routed back to the Mohammad Ali Jauhar Trust as donations.

The money laundering investigation in the matter was launched on the basis of around 26 first information reports registered by the Uttar Pradesh Police in 2019, Bar and Bench reported.

Edited by Sara Varghese.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097147/azam-khan-granted-bail-in-ed-case-allahabad-hc-says-arrest-motivated?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Wed, 18 Nov 2026 09:11:28 +0000 Scroll Staff
J&K: Lashkar-e-Taiba commander killed in Kulgam gunfight https://scroll.in/latest/1097150/j-k-lashkar-e-taibas-lateef-bhat-killed-in-kulgam-gunfight?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Lateef Bhat was wanted for his alleged involvement in an attack on the Central Reserve Police Force on November 11.

Lateef Bhat, a commander of the Lashkar-e-Taiba terror group, was killed in a gunfight in Kulgam on Wednesday, said the Jammu and Kashmir Police.

Bhat carried a bounty of Rs 15 lakh and was wanted for his alleged involvement in an attack on the Central Reserve Police Force on November 11, in which three security personnel were killed.

The militant was also allegedly involved in the attacks in Anantnag and Kulgam districts in July, according to reports.

Senior Superintendent of Police Anayat Ali Choudhary said that the security forces “had a long conversation” with the militant on the phone, The Hindu reported.

“We asked him to surrender but he refused,” the newspaper quoted Choudhary as saying. “We exercised maximum restraint given he was hiding inside a mosque.”

Central Reserve Police Force Director General GP Singh said on social media that “some dishes are best served cold, even in cold weather”.

Written by Nachiket Deuskar. Edited by Sara Varghese.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097150/j-k-lashkar-e-taibas-lateef-bhat-killed-in-kulgam-gunfight?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Wed, 18 Nov 2026 09:04:34 +0000 Scroll Staff
CEC protests: Delhi Police says sexual assault case against officers by women journalists closed https://scroll.in/latest/1097151/cec-protests-delhi-police-says-sexual-assault-case-against-officers-by-women-journalists-closed?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt There was no strict rule requiring only female police personnel to handle women during crowd-control operations, the police submitted in Supreme Court.

The Delhi Police has told the Supreme Court that allegations by three women journalists that police officers sexually assaulted them while they were reporting on protests against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar in New Delhi in October could not be corroborated, Bar and Bench reported on Wednesday.

The police said that the three complaints had been closed.

One of the journalists had alleged that Delhi Assistant Commissioner of Police Vivek Bhagat groped her while she was recording the detention of student leader Neha Bora during a demonstration at Jantar Mantar on October 3. Bhagat, who belongs to a Scheduled Caste community, had subsequently filed an FIR accusing the journalist of making casteist remarks during the protest. The investigation into the case is ongoing.

The protests, organised by Opposition parties, student groups and the Cockroach Janta Party political campaign, demanded Kumar’s resignation over alleged irregularities in the conduct of the special intensive revision of electoral rolls.

In its affidavit filed before the Supreme Court, the Delhi Police said that two of the three journalists did not wish to pursue their complaints, while the third did not join the police inquiry. It added that an examination of CCTV footage had not detected any act of sexual assault, Bar and Bench reported.

The Delhi Police also told the Supreme Court that there was no strict rule requiring only women police personnel to handle women during crowd-control operations, The Hindu reported.

It added that the presence or involvement of male police personnel in crowd-control operations during the protest could not, by itself, be construed as misconduct.

The affidavit also said that the Supreme Court’s October 11 direction to the Delhi Police not to “hinder” journalists, lawyers and other professionals in the discharge of their duties did not extend to “so-called reel-makers and social media influencers”, Live Law reported.

The Delhi Police said that it had not knowingly obstructed any journalist from carrying out their duties, Bar and Bench reported.

During the protests against Kumar in October, several journalists, including three from Scroll, were detained while reporting on demonstrations in Delhi and other parts of the country.

In the affidavit the Delhi Police submitted that the police action was directed towards “dispersing and removing the protestors from the illegal protest sites and restoring public order”, The Hindu reported.

It was “neither intended nor directed towards detaining, restraining or obstructing any media personnel in the lawful discharge of their professional duties”, the police added.

Edited by Tanya Shrivastava.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097151/cec-protests-delhi-police-says-sexual-assault-case-against-officers-by-women-journalists-closed?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Wed, 18 Nov 2026 08:32:27 +0000 Scroll Staff
Abhishek Banerjee reiterates allegations of BJP pressure on judiciary hours after contempt notice https://scroll.in/latest/1097146/abhishek-banerjee-reiterates-allegations-of-bjp-pressure-on-judiciary-hours-after-contempt-notice?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The TMC MP accused judges of ‘double standards’ in matters pertaining to BJP leaders and Opposition politicians.

Trinamool Congress MP Abhishek Banerjee on Tuesday reiterated his allegation that a section of the judiciary was acting “under influence” of the Bharatiya Janata Party, hours after the Calcutta High Court initiated criminal contempt proceedings against him for similar remarks, ANI reported.

The MP denied accusing any judge of being a member or colluding with the ruling party, but said “that they are certainly under pressure from the BJP”.

He added that many judges continued to remain impartial.

The TMC leader also accused the judiciary of “double standards” in matters pertaining to BJP leaders and Opposition politicians.

He questioned why similar action had not been taken against members of the Hindutva party about their remarks about the judiciary.

He asked: “Is it because I am not with the BJP? Would the rules be different for me if I were?”

Banerjee cited BJP MP Nishikant Dubey’s April 2025 remarks alleging that Sanjiv Khanna, the chief justice at the time, was responsible for “all civil wars” in the country. The TMC leader questioning why no contempt proceedings had been initiated against him.

In May 2025, the Supreme Court called Dubey’s allegation as “highly irresponsible” but refrained from taking contempt action saying public confidence in the credibility of courts cannot be shaken by “such absurd statements”.

Banerjee added that “if the judiciary claims to be neutral, then that neutrality and impartiality should be clearly reflected in its actions”.

On Tuesday, the High Court initiated criminal contempt proceedings against Banerjee, observing that his remarks appeared to interfere with the judicial process. It directed him to respond within 15 days as to why he should not be punished.

Banerjee had allegedly insinuated in comments made to the media that his application seeking improved security had been pending before the court as judicial decisions were being influenced by judges’ political affiliations.

The TMC MP had moved the court challenging the reduction of his security from Z+ category to X category by the BJP government in West Bengal. He alleged that the decision was politically motivated.

On Tuesday, the court also directed the government to review Banerjee’s security arrangement within two weeks.

Edited by Sara Varghese.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097146/abhishek-banerjee-reiterates-allegations-of-bjp-pressure-on-judiciary-hours-after-contempt-notice?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Wed, 18 Nov 2026 04:21:44 +0000 Scroll Staff
The prescience of Indian scholars who presented alternatives to today’s dominant development model https://scroll.in/article/1096821/the-wisdom-of-indian-scholars-who-presented-alternatives-to-todays-dominant-development-model?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt ‘Development’ had indeed occurred in India and globally. But it had not always made life better, and frequently made it worse, for the large majority of people.

The concept of development was among the central ideas that powered the anti-colonial freedom struggle in India in the early 1900s. By the 1940s, the dominant argument of nationalism was that colonial rule was impeding the development of India, social scientist Partha Chatterjee has written, and it had to be removed for the country to achieve progress.

After Independence, the Indian state pursued the nationalist ambitions of development with so much gusto that within just two decades it had made day-to-day life significantly better – although just for a few sections of the population: the upper and middle classes.

The acclaimed Films Division documentary I am 20 from 1967 features striking examples of the development experience of these elites of India. Some of the youth interviewed for the film expressed sentiments such as “I would say I am better off than my father was in almost every respect”; “Well, I think I need 50 sarees”; and “Of course [my needs] are more. I have more money to buy things…I see more things in the market, so I buy them.”

However, by the 1970s, serious doubts about the appropriateness of the state’s chosen paths to development were beginning to be expressed more prominently in the mainstream public discourse – though such scepticism and opposition had been an everyday experience for India’s subaltern communities for much longer.

In the mid-1970s, the Indian Council of Social Sciences Research initiated a research project titled “Alternatives in Development”. As part of this endeavour, the prolific scholar Rajni Kothari published a two-part article series titled “Alternatives in Development” for the ICSSR newsletter in 1979, expounding in detail the philosophy behind the project.

Like many thinkers and activists around the world at that time, Kothari focused his analysis primarily on “modern industrial civilisation” and the “approach to science and technology” that was steering India’s development efforts. He recalled the 1955 “Russell-Einstein manifesto”, in which some prominent scientists had appealed for global disarmament and peace efforts and declared that “there lies before us, if we choose, continual progress in happiness, knowledge and wisdom”.

However, to Kothari, the “new Paradise” promised by these scientists did “not seem so clear” 20 years later, with the world instead marked by a plethora of injustices and inequities. Modern science had done humanity immense good, and liberated people from the “horrors of nature and the horrors of religious doctrine” . But the “existing paradigms” were such that science and technology were being primarily used as “an instrument of power and domination rather than as a liberator of the human spirit”, he wrote.

Employing an analysis that will be familiar to progressive political economic thinkers today, including advocates of what has been labeled “degrowth”, Kothari wrote that the myth of perpetual progress, expounded by prominent elites of the time, had been busted. This myth – or perhaps a ruse – was deployed to convince the general public that it was possible to make growth and progress “infinite and unending and hence available to all”.

But contrary to such a rosy state of affairs, humanity was facing serious threats: “the threat of total war, the threat of extreme deprivation coexisting with over-abundance, the threat of the collapse of the biosphere [or the environment]”.

To Kothari and others like him, it was clear that the primary cause behind the distressing state of affairs was the “acquisitive ethic” of modern living, and the “pursuit of a parasitic and wasteful style of life” that was eating up a large majority of resources across the globe.

The “acquisitive ethic” is starkly visible, on a more everyday scale, in the documentary I am 20: for example, in the lifestyles of those young Indians who considered it necessary to possess “50 sarees” and to constantly buy “things in the market”.

Indeed, Kothari grouped Global South elites with the people of “Western” nations, arguing that the former had embraced the wasteful lifestyles and philosophies of the latter.

So in addition to the domination of the nations of the South by those of the North, there was also, within Global South regions, “domination of large masses of the people by small, privileged, mainly urban-based and westernised, elites which are more closely tied to the metropolitan centres of the world than to their own peoples”.

Basically, “development” had indeed occurred in India and globally, but it had not always made life better, and frequently made it worse, for the large majority of people. As Kothari wrote, a century of “unprecedented material progress” had also been one of “sprawling misery and increasing deprivation”.

To him, this basic contradiction meant that the path forward needed to be through a radical reimagining and overhaul of existing systems. He asserted that India needed, for example, land reforms and redistribution such that the “available land is able to provide employment and a minimum income to many more millions of families”; massive public works programmes “to construct durable community assets and to restore local resource endowments”; and the encouragement of “new and small-scale industries” for the manufacture of goods used by the general public.

The quest for development alternatives was a significant academic and activist project in India in the 1970s and later, and one of its major vehicles was the Indo-Dutch Programme for Alternatives in Development, the memorandum for which was signed in 1975 by ICSSR’s Member-Secretary JP Naik.

Naik was also involved in projects which attempted to reimagine healthcare in India and propose alternatives in that domain. He was a member of the influential Srivastav Committee which came out with its report in 1975 under the title “Health Services And Medical Education: A Programme For Immediate Action”. It was on the recommendations of this committee that India instituted its first nation-wide community health workers network in 1977, anticipating the network of ASHA workers by about 40 years.

In alignment with the general “Alternatives in Development” philosophy, the Srivastav report argued that India had devoted disproportionately more resources towards high-end hospitals and the training of doctors, and that policymakers needed to reorient health systems to more local and community-based needs.

To quote Naik: “After 30 years of development of health services, we find ourselves in the position of a traveller who sets out on a long journey, and even before he has travelled about three-tenths of the distance to his goal, finds that his purse has been stolen, his car has developed serious trouble and grave doubts have arisen even about the correctness of the route he had decided to follow.”

Unfortunately for the “Alternatives” advocates – and for most of us – very few of the multiple proposals and ideas that came out of this intellectual ferment in the 1970s-’80s were taken seriously in the corridors of power.

The elites’ deadly “acquisitive ethic” which Kothari presciently diagnosed, and the paradox of extreme deprivation coexisting with over-abundance, have gotten significantly worse over the decades.

Even in healthcare, despite the rhetorical attention given to ASHA workers and community-based healthcare, India has continued to follow, and significantly amplify, the doctor-, hospital-, and technology-centric models critiqued by Naik and others.

In recent years the environmental disasters in the Himalayan region in northern India, and the August flash flood disaster in Nepal, yet again catalysed calls to explore alternatives. Commentators, not unlike Naik and Kothari half a century ago, urged for a “fresh stock-taking, and a questioning of the capital-centric development model”.

It is anybody’s guess whether alternatives to the existing paradigms of development – “vikas” – will be considered seriously in India today, especially with the political regime more interested in implementing alternatives to democracy and the Constitution.

Nevertheless, increasingly more people, especially young folks, are realising that science and technology (for example, artificial intelligence) are being primarily used as “an instrument of power and domination rather than as a liberator of the human spirit” and that the constant reiteration by elites that growth is “infinite and unending and hence available to all” is bunkum.

One can hope that this realisation, combined with the increasingly widespread lived experiences of deprivation and disaster, will eventually lead to a reinvigorated interest in creating and implementing better alternatives to the current dominant modes of development.

The elites of India and the world have been content with offering to make tiny tweaks now and then to the political economy wheel, but Kothari and others show that the only real solution to our interconnected challenges today is a complete reinvention of the wheel.

Kiran Kumbhar is historian of India, medicine, and public health based in the US.

]]>
https://scroll.in/article/1096821/the-wisdom-of-indian-scholars-who-presented-alternatives-to-todays-dominant-development-model?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Wed, 18 Nov 2026 03:30:00 +0000 Kiran Kumbhar
Indian seafarer missing, two injured after attack on LPG tanker off Oman coast https://scroll.in/latest/1097145/indian-seafarer-missing-two-injured-after-attack-on-lpg-tanker-off-the-coast-of-oman?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Twenty-four Indian citizens were on board MT Tara Gas, out of which 21 have been safely evacuated and brought to shore.

One Indian citizen was missing and two sustained injuries after a Panama-flagged liquefied petroleum gas tanker came under attack on Monday in the Strait of Hormuz, the Ministry of External Affairs said in a statement.

Twenty-four Indian citizens were on board the vessel, MT Tara Gas, out of which 21 have been safely evacuated and brought to shore at Khasab in Oman, the foreign ministry said.

The injured seafarers were admitted to hospital and a search was ongoing to locate the missing person.

New Delhi was closely monitoring the search and rescue operations in coordination with the Omani authorities, the statement added.

The ministry condemned Monday’s attack and said that such incidents were “deeply worrisome”. It called for the targeting of shipping vessels to end and for “free, unimpeded navigation and commerce” to be restored under international law.

The incident came amid a series of attacks on commercial vessels in West Asia since the conflict began in February.

On November 2, an Indian seafarer was killed and 13 were rescued after an “unidentified aerial object” struck the Indian-flagged MSV Al Jusufi while it was passing through the Strait of Hormuz off the coast of Oman.

On October 28, the Ministry of External Affairs said 22 Indians had been killed in the West Asia conflict since February, including 14 seafarers.

The war in West Asia began when the United States and Israel launched an attack on Iran on February 28, claiming that Tehran’s action posed an existential threat to Israel. Washington acts as a guarantor of Israel’s security. Iran retaliated by striking Israel and US military bases in the region, targeting major cities in Gulf countries and ships.

On June 15, the US and Iran arrived at an interim agreement to stop the fighting and reopen the Strait of Hormuz for commercial vessels. However, diplomatic efforts to end the war have largely stalled since then.

On November 10, United States President Donald Trump said he thinks the war on Iran could end “fairly soon”, adding that he sees a “positive momentum” toward the conclusion of the conflict as Israel and West Asia were protected from “Iranian danger”.

Written by Abeer Khan. Edited by Sara Varghese.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097145/indian-seafarer-missing-two-injured-after-attack-on-lpg-tanker-off-the-coast-of-oman?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Wed, 18 Nov 2026 03:19:39 +0000 Scroll Staff
It is not only Delhi’s rich who are leaving the city to escape pollution https://scroll.in/article/1097141/it-is-not-only-delhis-rich-who-are-leaving-the-city-to-escape-pollution?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Accounts have emerged of relatively privileged families leaving for less polluted cities. But a few poorer residents have also migrated to protect their health.

When Mohammad Najir first started working as a waste collector, the Bhalswa landfill, one of three landfills in Delhi, was almost flat. Over the next two decades, during which he collected waste door-to-door in different parts of the city and segregated it, he saw the landfill grow into a mountain.

As the landfill grew, Najir’s health declined.

First, in 2007, he was diagnosed with tuberculosis, for which he was on medication for eight months. His respiratory troubles persisted in the years that followed, and by 2018, Najir was no longer fit enough to do garbage-collecting work.

Then, around 2019, he developed asthma. His breathlessness and persistent cough worried his wife, Manoura Begum, who also worked as a waste collector. She noticed that Najir’s symptoms grew worse whenever the colder months rolled in.

Two years ago, Begum devised a plan on the advice of her mother-in-law – she and her sons told Najir that they wanted to travel to Najir’s ancestral village in the district of Madhubani in Bihar, to spend time with their extended family. When they all reached Madhubani, she told Najir that while their sons would return, the couple would stay on in the village. “We hoped that the cleaner air in the village would make his health better,” Begum said. “He was surprised at first, but then agreed.”

Begum stayed with Najir in Madhubani for a year – but their plan encountered a hurdle. While Najir’s health did not allow him to work, Begum was unable to find work. As their costs piled up, Begum decided to return to Delhi’s Baprola area, where her sons lived, leaving Najir behind. “Now we have to live separately, and I am the main earning member,” said Begum. Najir remains in Madhubani, and spends much of his day at rest.

Around the same year that Begum decided to move her husband out of Delhi, Kalu, a flower-seller on the roads of RK Puram and Moti Bagh, was considering a similar plan.

Kalu’s four-year-old son, the youngest of three, had been suffering with frequent eye infections and a persistent cough. A doctor they consulted said that the child’s problems were a result of exposure to dust, pollution and vehicle emissions. He prescribed medication for a week, which gave the boy some respite. “But his health did not improve drastically. We then took the call to move out of the city,” Kalu told Scroll over the phone.

While he first moved his family back to their native village in Rajasthan’s Bhilwara district, he did not find any work there, and so subsequently migrated nearly 1,700 km south to Bengaluru.

Najir and Kalu’s family are what some refer to as “smog refugees” – people who, to safeguard their health, relocate from polluted places to less polluted ones.

In India, most such instances that have been reported involve migration out of Delhi, which is one of the world's most polluted capitals, and has seen only between 50 and 100 “good” and “satisfactory” air quality days annually in the last seven years.

Typically, such individuals and families are relatively privileged, and have the financial resources to manage such a move comfortably. More recently, however, some lower-income households have also been undertaking similar moves at considerable financial strain – though such cases are far rarer.

For these families, the costs are not just financial – when Kalu left Delhi, for instance, he had to remove his two elder children from the government school in which they were enrolled. In Bengaluru, he has not yet enrolled them in any school. “The government school is far from where we stay,” Kalu said.

Occupational hazards

As we climbed up four floors on a smoggy Sunday afternoon to reach Begum’s home in Delhi’s Baprola, she recounted that before he left, her husband had struggled to do the climb several times a day.

Inside her one-room unit, which she shared with her two sons and a grandson, she explained that since she and her husband had worked with garbage for several decades, they were more vulnerable than most to respiratory diseases. “Collecting unsegregated garbage from home to home meant that there would be wet and dry waste together,” she said.

When they segregated the collected waste later, she explained, toxic fumes would emanate from it, especially in the hotter months. “As collectors, we are the closest to these fumes and bacteria,” she said.

Over the phone from Bihar, Najir spoke more about this problem. “Add to this the fires that garbage sites often catch in the summer, all that smoke is toxic to breath,” he said, taking frequent breaks from speaking to cough. “Just walking or lifting heavy weights would make me breathless in Delhi.”

As his health continued to deteriorate, particularly in the months with higher AQI levels, doctors told Najir to avoid dust and smoke. One said that it was likely that he had developed tuberculosis and asthma because of the nature of his work.

Indeed, studies have found a link between the kind of work he did and his health troubles. A 2023 report by the Chintan Environmental Research and Action Group compared the health data of 100 waste pickers, safai karamcharis and security guards in Delhi with that of a group that did not engage in these jobs.

The study found that 75% of the waste pickers had abnormal pulmonary function, that 17% of them suffered from severe lung diseases, and that 26% of them reported difficulty in breathing. In contrast, 45% of participants of the control group had abnormal lung function, and none had severe lung diseases.

Further, those engaged in such work typically see ailments such as tuberculosis and asthma exacerbated as a result of exposure to Delhi’s polluted air, explained Dr Shiva Kant Misra, CEO at Kanpur’s Shivani Hospital and IVF, and a member of the Doctors for Clean Air movement. “When toxic air with carbon monoxide or ozone, along with dust and smoke, which creates PM 2.5 and PM 10, goes into the lungs, it creates an allergy, an irritant,” Misra explained. “And if a patient already has these diseases, their lung function is already bad. Then these symptoms can increase multifold.”

Misra added that the ailments can have a particularly strong impact on women, older people and young children. Indeed, a 2018 study focused on Agra found that “exposure to traffic‑related air pollution is associated with an increased risk of respiratory morbidity in children”. Further, if children had preexisting asthma or lower respiratory tract disease, this exposure could worsen their condition. “Asthmatic episodes were 1.79 times more in children, who were residing in proximity to traffic,” the study found.

The doctor that Kalu consulted for his son said that the boy’s continued exposure to vehicular exhaust and emissions could have triggered his persistent cough. But this exposure was unavoidable, since he and his wife spent the entire day on footpaths selling flowers.

The costs of leaving the city

Begum explained that when her family relocated, they did not only have to incur the costs of travel, but also account for the fact that they would not immediately find work to support themselves. “For families like us, such a relocation means that we have to save at least two-three months of our earnings,” Begum said.

After returning to Delhi, to support the family, and Najir in Madhubani, Begum initially worked as part of the cleaning staff of an office in Netaji Nagar – but the office shut down eventually, leaving her unemployed for several months. Earlier in November, she began working in a factory that makes electrical parts. “I send whatever little I earn back home,” she said, adding that Najir met the costs of his medication with this money.

Economic and other other costs rise if a family moves further away. Kalu, for instance, noted that since his family moved to Bengaluru, “going home and returning to the city means at least a three-day journey each way in the train”. In contrast, “From Delhi, it was just a day’s journey away.” The family travels around once in four months to Bhilwara – if the children were in schools, they would have to miss several days during their long journeys and the time they spend in the village, Kalu explained. “This was another reason we did not admit them to schools in Bengaluru,” he said.

But Kalu observed that his son is in better health – this is unsurprising, given that Bengaluru is among cities in India that have the cleanest air, with AQI that ranged between 65 and 90 between 2015 and 2025. While the family is still selling flowers on the road in Bengaluru, Kalu has made a small shed where his wife and children spend most of the day arranging the flowers. “In Delhi, the police would often bother us, and would not let us make any such temporary shop,” he said.

But in the case of Najir, most of the damage is already done. “The breathlessness has reduced,” he said over the phone. “But I am okay only as long as I am on medicines.”

Experts point out that those like Najir, who move from cities to which they migrated, back to their places of origin, can also face adverse psychological consequences. “Unlike the rich, who can afford to make these decisions, even whimsically, of say, spending a few weeks in Shimla to escape pollution in Delhi, for lower-income families such decisions can rattle people’s identities,” said Arjun Kamdar, a conservation scientist and doctoral candidate at Cambridge University, whose research is at the intersection of behavioural economics, psychology and conservation.

Kamdar explained that those who migrate from villages to cities often do so because they aspire to a better quality of life. “Then, to wrap that life up can also be emotionally wrenching,” he said. “Their social standing can take a hit, the fact that they went to the city, and did not make it.”

Still not an option for many

For many residents who are suffering impacts of air pollution in Delhi, leaving is not even an option.

Virender Kumar is the programme director of the Waste Picker Welfare Foundation, and has been working with waste pickers in Delhi’s Ghazipur for over a decade. Several of them live and work near a waste-to-energy plant situated near the Ghazipur landfill – such plants convert municipal waste into electricity through the process of incineration. They have, however, been known to be air polluting.

“Many women workers we work with have had premature deliveries,” said Kumar. One study found that when mothers are exposed to high PM 2.5 during pregnancies, 13% of cases saw premature births, while 17% saw babies born with low birth weight.

Kumar noted that he had also encountered men suffering from kidney and lung diseases. “But no one is thinking of moving out of the city to manage their health,” he said. He added that many of the workers he worked with migrated from West Bengal and Assam, and did not have lands back home. “What will they do after going home? What will they earn and what will they eat?” Kumar said. “Leaving the city is not an option for them.”

Begum was aware that families like hers, which had relocated to escape pollution, were few in number. “Where will people go after leaving the city?” she said. “And till when will they continue running from air like this?”

]]>
https://scroll.in/article/1097141/it-is-not-only-delhis-rich-who-are-leaving-the-city-to-escape-pollution?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Wed, 18 Nov 2026 01:00:03 +0000 Vaishnavi Rathore
Delhi: GRAP-3 curbs revoked as air quality improves to ‘poor’ category https://scroll.in/latest/1097139/delhi-grap-3-curbs-revoked-as-air-quality-improves-to-poor-category?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Stage 3 restrictions were introduced on November 6 as a precaution after air quality worsened to the ‘severe’ category ahead of Diwali.

The Commission for Air Quality Management on Tuesday revoked Stage 3 restrictions under the Graded Response Action Plan in Delhi and the National Capital Region after air quality improved to the “poor” category.

Stage 3 measures were imposed on November 6 as a precaution after air quality worsened to the “severe” category ahead of Diwali.

GRAP is a set of incremental anti-pollution measures that are triggered to prevent further worsening of air quality once it reaches a certain threshold in Delhi-NCR.

The commission said Delhi recorded an average Air Quality Index of 204 on Tuesday. The forecasts by the India Meteorological Department and the Indian Institute of Tropical Meteorology indicated that air quality was likely to “remain in poor/very poor category in coming days”, it added.

As of 6.05 pm, Delhi recorded an average AQI of 198, according to the Sameer application, which provides hourly updates published by the Central Pollution Control Board.

Thirty of the 58 active monitoring stations recorded “poor” air quality with Chandni Chowk and Sirifort recording the highest readings at 288.

An index value between 0 and 50 indicates “good” air quality, between 51 and 100 indicates “satisfactory” air quality and between 101 and 200 indicates “moderate” air quality. As the index value increases further, air quality deteriorates. A value of 201 and 300 means “poor” air quality, while between 301 and 400 indicates “very poor” air.

Between 401 and 450 indicates “severe” air pollution, while anything above the 450 threshold is termed “severe plus”.

The commission said that restrictions under the first two stages were introduced on October 21 and November 2 would remain in force.

The second stage of GRAP involves a ban on the use of coal and firewood, including tandoors in hotels, restaurants and open eateries. It also includes a ban on the use of diesel generator sets, except for emergency and essential services.

It further comprises measures such as the mechanical sweeping of roads and sprinkling water on them to keep the dust from rising, and intensified inspections for strict dust control measures at construction and demolition sites.

The first stage involves measures such as mechanical sweeping of roads and sprinkling water on them to keep dust from rising.

Air quality deteriorates sharply in the winter months in Delhi, which is often ranked the world’s most polluted capital. The lighting of firecrackers during Diwali, along with stubble burning in Punjab and Haryana, vehicular pollution, falling temperatures, decreased wind speeds and emissions from industries and coal-fired plants contribute to the problem.

This year, Diwali was celebrated on November 8. Peak air pollution levels are historically observed during and immediately after Diwali.

On Friday, the average AQI in Delhi had worsened to “severe” category.

Written by Anamika Pathak. Edited by Tanya Shrivastava.


Also read:


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097139/delhi-grap-3-curbs-revoked-as-air-quality-improves-to-poor-category?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Tue, 17 Nov 2026 13:52:29 +0000 Scroll Staff
Rush Hour: UP adds 19 lakh voters ahead of polls, Bilkis to challenge SC relief to 2 convicts & more https://scroll.in/latest/1097131/rush-hour-up-adds-19-lakh-voters-ahead-of-polls-bilkis-to-challenge-sc-relief-to-2-convicts-more?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Become a Scroll member to get Rush Hour – a wrap of the day’s important stories delivered straight to your inbox every evening.

Could your home be at risk from rising seas? Scroll is investigating coastal flooding in Mumbai and Kolkata, mapping vulnerable areas and examining whether developers and the authorities are accounting for the risks. Support this investigation and help us make this reporting possible. Fund the project here.


More than 18.8 lakh persons were added to the draft voter list of Uttar Pradesh as part of the special summary revision. With this, the electorate in the state provisionally increased to 13.5 crore ahead of the Assembly elections early next year.

The increase in voters is the first since the final list following the special intensive revision of electoral rolls was published in April. While the voter lists are prepared afresh during the special intensive revision, the special summary revision involves the addition and deletion of voters from existing rolls.

The special summary revision comes at a time when Chief Minister Adityanath has alleged that the names of 1.2 crore Hindu voters were missing from the electoral rolls amid the special intensive revision. He has also claimed that there had been a 1.6% increase in Muslim electors. While it was not clear which data the chief minister was citing, the claims sparked an exchange between the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party and the Opposition. Read on.


Attorney General R Venkataramani granted consent for initiating criminal contempt proceedings against an advocate for making purportedly objectionable remarks about Chief Justice Surya Kant. A day earlier advocate Pravin Singhal approached a bench headed by Kant seeking an urgent hearing on a matter relating to allegations of corruption in the judiciary.

Singhal told the court that he had submitted papers related to the case to the chief justice’s office on November 2, but had not received any response. When Kant asked Singhal to wait, the advocate refused and allegedly said that Kant “does not deserve” to hold the position of chief justice.

Following the remarks, the audio-video feed of the proceedings was switched off and Singhal was escorted out of the courtroom by security personnel. Read on.


Bilkis Bano said she will challenge the Supreme Court order that suspended the life sentences of two men convicted of raping her and murdering members of her family, and granted them bail. The two convicts are among the 11 men whose premature release by the Gujarat government in August 2022 was quashed by the Supreme Court in 2024.

The 11 men had been convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment for raping Bano and murdering 14 members of her family during the 2002 communal riots in the state.

In an order passed on October 28, the Supreme Court said that the two men had been jailed for more than 17 years and that there were matters that needed to be decided in their appeals. The order was first reported a day earlier. Read on.


A United States federal judge struck down a policy imposed by President Donald Trump that would impose stricter visa limits on how long international students and journalists can study or work in the US. The ruling came from an appeal filed against the Department of Homeland Security by a coalition of unions representing universities, teachers and journalists.

The new rules that were announced in July were expected to impact international students with F visas, visitors on cultural exchange programmes who possess a J visa and foreign journalists with an I visa.

Under the proposed new rules, international students would be allowed to stay in the US for a maximum of up to four years after which they would have to apply for an extension. Previously, foreigners on student visas were allowed to stay for the entire duration of their studies. Read on.


If you haven’t already, sign up for our Daily Brief newsletter.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097131/rush-hour-up-adds-19-lakh-voters-ahead-of-polls-bilkis-to-challenge-sc-relief-to-2-convicts-more?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Tue, 17 Nov 2026 12:59:48 +0000 Scroll Staff
In first update since SIR, over 18 lakh voters added to Uttar Pradesh electoral rolls https://scroll.in/latest/1097137/in-first-update-since-sir-over-18-lakh-voters-added-to-uttar-pradesh-electoral-rolls?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt The final voter list after the special summary revision will be published on January 4, ahead of the Assembly elections.

More than 18.8 lakh persons were added to the draft voter list of Uttar Pradesh as part of their special summary revision.

With this, the electorate in the state provisionally increased to 13.5 crore ahead of the Assembly elections early next year.

The increase in voters is the first since the final list following the special intensive revision of electoral rolls was published in April.

While the voter lists are prepared afresh during the special intensive revision, the special summary revision involves the addition and deletion of voters from existing rolls.

The claims and objections period will be till December 16, during which persons can apply to be included, or to seek deletions or corrections. The applications will be cleared by December 28, before the final rolls are published on January 4.

Of the 18.8 lakh added to the draft list, more than 10.9 lakh are men and 7.8 lakh are women.

The annual special summary revision was paused after the 2024 Lok Sabha elections because of the special intensive revision, which began in 2025. The latter is underway in some states and Union Territories.

Besides Uttar Pradesh, the special summary revision is being held in 16 states and Union Territories in this phase.

In nine of the 16 states and Union Territories, where compatible data was immediately available, the increase in the number of voters ranged from 0.1% to 3% in the first draft electoral rolls published after the special intensive revision.

The special summary revision comes at a time when Chief Minister Adityanath has alleged that the names of 1.2 crore Hindu voters were missing from the electoral rolls amid the special intensive revision. He has also claimed that there had been a 1.6% increase in Muslim electors.

It was not clear which data the chief minister was citing, but the claims had sparked an exchange between the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party and the Opposition.

Samajwadi Party chief Akhilesh Yadav had earlier urged the Election Commission to clarify where Adityanath got the data about deleted voters. Terming it a conspiracy, he said the BJP is trying to create fear in society.

On Tuesday, Uttar Pradesh Chief Electoral Officer Navdeep Rinwa said that the Election Commission does not maintain data on voters’ religion or caste, or conduct official analyses based on these categories.

“We do not have any data in this regard,” Rinwa said.

He said that the electoral database contains details such as voters' names, their fathers' or spouses' names, age, house numbers and gender.

Rinwa added that electoral rolls can be downloaded from the Election Commission's website and that media organisations and independent analysts may have conducted their own assessments using names and other available details. Such analyses should not be treated as official data or findings of the election department, he said.

Written by Nachiket Deuskar and Anamika Pathak. Edited by Tanya Shrivastava.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097137/in-first-update-since-sir-over-18-lakh-voters-added-to-uttar-pradesh-electoral-rolls?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Tue, 17 Nov 2026 11:34:49 +0000 Scroll Staff
Attorney general allows contempt proceedings against lawyer for remarks about CJI https://scroll.in/latest/1097132/attorney-general-allows-contempt-proceedings-against-lawyer-for-remarks-about-cji?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Advocate Pravin Singhal had said in the courtroom on Monday that Surya Kant ‘does not deserve’ to hold the position of the chief justice.

Attorney General R Venkataramani on Tuesday granted consent for initiating criminal contempt proceedings against an advocate for making allegedly objectionable remarks about Chief Justice Surya Kant, Bar and Bench reported.

On Monday, advocate Pravin Singhal approached a bench headed by Kant seeking an urgent hearing on a matter relating to allegations of corruption in the judiciary, the legal news outlet reported.

Singhal told the court that he had submitted papers related to the case to the chief justice’s office on November 2, but had not received any response.

When Kant asked Singhal to wait, the advocate refused and allegedly said that Kant “does not deserve” to hold the position of chief justice, the legal news outlet reported.

“You cannot sit in that chair,” Bar and Bench quoted Singhal as saying. “You do not deserve. You do not have the integrity for that.”

Following the remarks, the audio-video feed of the proceedings was switched off and Singhal was escorted out of the courtroom by security personnel, Live Law reported.

In a letter to the Supreme Court Bar Association on Tuesday, Venkataramani described the remarks as “extremely scandalous and unpardonable”. The association had sought to initiate contempt proceedings against Singhal.

Kant said that the petition would be listed for hearing on Wednesday.

Edited by Nachiket Deuskar.


]]>
https://scroll.in/latest/1097132/attorney-general-allows-contempt-proceedings-against-lawyer-for-remarks-about-cji?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Tue, 17 Nov 2026 10:07:00 +0000 Scroll Staff
Readers’ comments: Amitabha Bagchi’s misplaced defence of Urdu writer Khalid Jawed https://scroll.in/article/1097092/readers-comments-amitabha-bagchis-misplaced-defence-of-urdu-writer-khalid-jawed?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Responses to articles in Scroll.in.

Amitabha Bagchi frames the debate sparked by my critique of Khalid Jawed’s fiction around a vital question: What counts as originality in fiction? (“‘Shake off the aura’: Novelist Amitabha Bagchi on originality and borrowing in literary writing”).

While I appreciate his candid empathy about my “disappointment” and his acknowledgment that the parallels I traced across five novels are extensive and undeniable, his defense of borrowing, through examples like Tulsidas, Girish Karnad, and KJ Yesudas, conflates two fundamentally antithetical literary practices: homage and concealment.

When Tulsidas composed the Ramcharitmanas, he never claimed to have invented the narrative of Ram; he situated himself explicitly within a sacred, pre-existing tradition. When Girish Karnad wrote The Fire and the Rain (Agni Mattu Male), he openly cited the Mahabharata’s Yavakri myth in his preface, making the ancient text an active conversational partner in his dramaturgy.

When Yesudas sings “Ka karoon sajni”, it is an acknowledged rendition within the established pedagogical lineage of the Patiala gharana. In none of these instances did the artist attempt to pass off an imported, highly idiosyncratic structural blueprint as an ex nihilo miracle of personal genius.

The grievance against Khalid Jawed is not that fiction must be born in a vacuum – no serious critic makes that claim. The grievance is what legal theorist Richard A Posner accurately defines as the core of plagiarism: “The offense is not the theft of the work; it is the concealment of the author.”

It hardly intertextuality when an author extracts the precise, idiosyncratic narrative engine of Neil Gaiman’s The Sandman (a pregnancy conceived entirely in a dream world resulting in a real-world child who causes the progenitor’s death), lifts the exact temporal paradoxes of Netflix’s German series Dark, reproduces the claustrophobic monologues of Thomas Bernhard’s Concrete, and borrows the grotesque food inventories of Émile Zola – all while wrapping them in Bareilly's local stench and presenting them to the subcontinent as an unprecedented, “incomparable” metaphysical breakthrough. That is architectural appropriation practiced under the safety of an information asymmetry.

Bagchi astutely notes our shared cultural cringe when Bappi Lahiri lifts a Western pop track without credit, compared to our pride in a classical thumri’s lineage. Yet, he stops short of taking his own observation to its logical conclusion. The shame does not stem from postcolonial insecurity alone but from the erasure of authorship.

When Khalid Jawed credited Ingmar Bergman’s The Seventh Seal in his short story Taash ke Patton ka Ajaib Ghar, he demonstrated that he knows how and when homage ought to be paid. Why, then, did that ethical compass vanish across five major novels? Why was that transparency denied to Gaiman, Bernhard, Sontag, and Polanski?

Reading with “generosity and compassion” is a noble writerly virtue, but when generosity degenerates into institutional complicity – where juries and critics celebrate derivative structures as indigenous miracles simply because they carry an award’s seal – criticism ceases to be an act of discernment. To shake off the “aura”, as Bagchi suggests, we must first have the courage to switch on the flashlight, even if it exposes that the emperor’s clothes were tailored in London and Berlin.

– Ashar Najmi, author and editor, Asbaat

]]>
https://scroll.in/article/1097092/readers-comments-amitabha-bagchis-misplaced-defence-of-urdu-writer-khalid-jawed?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=dailyhunt Tue, 17 Nov 2026 10:00:00 +0000 Scroll